Wednesday, April 11, 2007
More on Law Firm Rejection Letters: The Best One I Heard
Posted by Alan Childress
Jeff's post on succinct or painful rejection letters reminded me of a story by a colleague of ours at Tulane who, as a law student seeking a law firm summer job, once received a rejection letter from a firm that she later tacked on her office door (the letter, not the firm). It is also a cautionary tale in removing metadata. The letter was standard in every way, even commenting that the firm had an unusual number of qualified applicants that year, these decisions are difficult, and the rejection does not mean the candidate does not have outstanding credentials or should avoid applying again in the future. The firm forgot to remove the document name at the bottom of the Word document, duly printed out on their letterhead: kissoff.doc.
Readers, hear of any other great rejection letters or faux pas? Getting rejected from a place you never applied to does not count. I think we all have stories of getting rejection letters out of the blue from law firms, judges, and law reviews despite the fact that we never actually applied. Please post your story, or one you've heard, in Comments.
Yay. Plaudits for the just and nice use of 'metadata' in perfect context.
Posted by: Simon Pride | Apr 11, 2007 8:44:57 AM
I received the ambiguous rejection, "We do not have a position for a person of your qualifications."
Posted by: | Apr 14, 2007 12:18:46 AM
OK, I will start, though mine is from a Justice not a law firm. The second rejection letter I received from Justice Blackmun specifically referenced the first rejection letter he'd sent me a year before. That takes diligence and caring.
I was once rejected by Potter Stewart and was relieved he did not say "...I know unqualified when I see it."
And Sandra Day O'Connor was a tough interview; she has unnerving eye contact that one tries to hold for a while but soon finds oneself doing a Stevie Wonder head sway.
Posted by: Childress | Apr 11, 2007 7:44:59 AM