Monday, April 26, 2021

Cert Denial (without Prejudice) in Texas et al. v. Cook County, IL et al.

Supreme-Court-Building-1920x720Today the U.S. Supreme Court declined to grant certiorari in Texas et al. v. Cook County, IL et al., a suit by Texas and thirteen states to defend Trump's public charge rule that makes it difficult to become a lawful permanent resident after using certain public benefits. The Court's order, which leaves open the possibility of a renewed review in the Supreme Court after first raising arguments in the District Court, reads in full as follows:

In 2019, the Department of Homeland Security promulgated through notice and comment a rule defining the term “public charge.” The District Court in this case vacated the rule nationwide, but that judgment was stayed pending DHS’s appeal to the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit. On March 9, 2021, following the change in presidential administration, DHS voluntarily dismissed that appeal, thereby dissolving the stay of the District Court’s judgment. And on March 15, DHS relied on the District Court’s now-effective judgment to remove the challenged rule from the Code of Federal Regulations without going through notice and comment rulemaking. Shortly after DHS had voluntarily dismissed its appeal, a group of States sought leave to intervene in the Court of Appeals. When that request was denied, the States filed an application for leave to intervene in this Court and for a stay of the District Court’s judgment. The States argue that DHS has prevented enforcement of the rule while insulating the District Court’s judgment from review. The States also contend that DHS has rescinded the rule without following the requirements of the Administrative Procedure Act. We deny the application, without prejudice to the States raising these and other arguments before the District Court, whether in a motion for intervention or otherwise. After the District Court considers any such motion, the States may seek review, if necessary, in the Court of Appeals, and in a renewed application in this Court.

More detailed reporting on the decision is available on Law360.

IE

https://lawprofessors.typepad.com/immigration/2021/04/cert-denial-without-prejudice-in-texas-et-al-v-cook-county-il-et-al.html

Current Affairs | Permalink

Comments

Post a comment