Thursday, September 17, 2020

Immigration Article of the Day: Inalienable Citizenship by Cassandra Burke Robertson and Irina Manta

Robertson_cassandra_burke

Irina manta

In honor of citizenship day, I'm highlighting the third in a series of articles on the topic by Cassandra Robertson and Irina Manta

Inalienable Citizenship, North Carolina Law Review, Forthcoming, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=

Abstract

Over the last decade, citizenship in the United States has become increasingly precarious. Denaturalization cases increased under President Obama and skyrocketed under President Trump. No number of years spent in the United States protects individuals against sudden accusations that they procured citizenship fraudulently or were never eligible for citizenship to begin with. Moreover, the government has challenged the citizenship status even of some individuals—largely from ethnic and religious minority communities—that the government had previously recognized as citizens for decades.

If the U.S. justice system is committed to the values of reliance and finality, how can it permit citizenship to be challenged without any time limit? American courts currently do not recognize a statute of limitations for civil denaturalization or apply the traditional doctrines of equitable estoppel or laches to this context. This state of affairs is partly based on judicial misunderstanding of the property-like features of citizenship and of the punitive nature of removing it. We argue that this must change. Denaturalization and citizenship denial undermine the foundation of our democratic system by tolerating second-class citizenship and promoting chilling effects against free speech and political participation. The time has come for the legislative and judicial branches to recognize that delayed citizenship challenges violate constitutional due-process protections. Security of citizenship is an essential bedrock of our constitutional order.

MHC

https://lawprofessors.typepad.com/immigration/2020/09/immigration-article-of-the-day-inalienable-citizenship-by-cassandra-robertson-and-irina-manta.html

Law Review Articles & Essays | Permalink

Comments

Post a comment