Thursday, August 22, 2024
The New Gender Perspective of Intersectional Autonomy in International Human Rights
Rose Celorio, The New Gender Perspective: The Dawn of Intersectional Autonomy in Women’s Rights,
25 Chi. J. of Int’l L. 67 (2024)
International human rights jurisprudence has increasingly mandated state action which integrates a gender perspective, taking into consideration the discriminatory norms, harmful social practices, stereotypes, and violence that women have and still suffer. A range of supranational bodies have issued case decisions promoting the adoption of gender-sensitive legislation, policies, programs, and the establishment of administration of justice systems well-trained and equipped to address women’s rights violations. This article discusses how the conception of this gender perspective has evolved over time and is now centered on the pursuit of autonomy for women. Autonomy is presented as a key ingredient to ensure due respect for women’s self-direction, agency, and dignity. This evolving approach is a move towards intersectional autonomy, which advances the notion that women should be the sole architects of their life plans, based on their identities and different experiences, and meaningfully participate in their societies. Creating the conditions for free and informed choices underpins current women’s rights jurisprudence. This is a break from historical notions of human rights protection solely focused on women as victims, as members of a homogenous group, and a limited binary perspective to their rights. This article discusses illustrative decisions of this tendency from the European Court of Human Rights, the Inter-American Commission and Court of Human Rights, the United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women, and the United Nations Human Rights Committee, among other bodies. This article further proposes that intersectional autonomy is treated and interpreted in the future in international jurisprudence as a right, with independent content, offering guidance to states on needed laws, policies, programs, and services at the local and national levels. This human rights development is presented as essential for international law standards concerning women to be impactful and truly transformative at the national level. This article analyzes the main elements of the right of women to intersectional autonomy, and states’ negative and positive obligations in its fulfillment. The author is currently pursuing a line of research exploring contemporary understandings of the international human rights of women, and how existing legal standards should evolve based on modern scenarios and realities. This article represents a contribution to this line of scholarship. It aims to increase understanding of the connection of the concepts of intersectional discrimination and autonomy, how they can be analyzed by global and regional human rights jurisprudence, and their promise to enhance effectiveness in international law concerning women.
https://lawprofessors.typepad.com/gender_law/2024/08/the-new-gender-perspective-of-intersectional-autonomy-in-international-human-rights.html