CrimProf Blog

Editor: Kevin Cole
Univ. of San Diego School of Law

Wednesday, July 1, 2020

Lord on Denunciation

Phil Lord (McGill University - Faculty of Law) has posted 'It Doesn’t Work!': The Symbolic Aspect of Law, From the Criminal Law to Bill 21 ((2020) 9:6 Directions 1) on SSRN. Here is the abstract:
This article uses an analytical framework from the criminal law to analyse Quebec’s Bill 21. It analyses denunciation, an important principle in the criminal law, and describes its analytical framework. It then applies this framework to Bill 21. From a historical analysis of the importance of state secularism in Quebec, it re-frames the debate regarding Bill 21 and paints Bill 21 as a symbolic and constitutive act. Bill 21 allows Quebecers to break free from an oppressive past defined by the confluence of church and state. As a symbolic act, it constitutes and consolidates a shared identity. It is underlain by shared anxieties regarding potential threats to this identity. By developing a criminal law framework, this article suggests, although tangentially, that the importance of the symbolic and constitutive aspects of law transcends the criminal law.

| Permalink


Post a comment