Thursday, February 11, 2010

Tyler on United States v. Klein

This paper might be of special interest to federal courts teachers who teach United States v. Klein. Professor Amanda L. Tyler (George Washington University Law School) has posted "The Story of Klein: The Scope of Congress's Authority to Shape the Jurisdiction of the Federal Courts" on SSRN.  It will be published in Jackson & Resnik's Federal Courts Stories.

The abstract states:

Almost 140 years after the Supreme Court handed down the decision, the Civil War-era case of United States v. Klein continues to baffle students and scholars alike. Indeed, as one observer has written, “Klein is sufficiently impenetrable that calling it opaque is a compliment.” But making sense of the decision has taken on new importance. For much of its history, Klein has stood as the only occasion on which the Supreme Court has struck down a limitation on federal court jurisdiction drafted as such by Congress. During the 2007 Supreme Court Term, however, the Court once again resisted an encroachment on its jurisdiction framed in such terms, and thereby invited a new round of debate over what limits govern Congress’s authority to shape the jurisdiction and powers of the judicial branch.


Federal Courts, Recent Scholarship, Subject Matter Jurisdiction, Supreme Court Cases | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Tyler on United States v. Klein:


Post a comment