Chinese Law Prof Blog

Editor: Donald C. Clarke
George Washington University Law School

Saturday, April 15, 2017

Full Private Land Ownership Returns to China’s Cities

{MAY 17th UPDATE: A much fuller and better piece about this development is available at the Foreign Affairs website here.]

Did that headline get your attention? If it’s an exaggeration, it’s not much of one.

Last week a student brought to my attention a statement Li Keqiang made last month that I and just about everyone else (I can’t be sure) seem to have missed. At a press conference at the end of the National People’s Congress session, Li announced that full private ownership of land has been restored in China’s cities. Of course, he didn’t use those exact words, but the effect of this statement was the same. Here’s why.

Since the mid-1990s, the state—the owner of all urban land—has sold long-term leaseholds in that land called “land-use rights” (LURs): a maximum of 70 years for residential use, 40 years for commercial use, and 50 years for everything else. These LURs are a lot like long-term leases in Western countries: you can sell them, and if the government takes them, it has to compensate you. There are restrictions on use, but they aren’t different in nature or degree from the zoning restrictions you see in market economies. (I’ve written in detail about the urban land regime here.)

Also like Western long-term leases, when they expire, they expire. If you want to keep using the land, you have to pay again. At least that used to be the rule. But everyone would like something for nothing, and after the new regime went into effect, LUR-holders began to complain that the rules about renewals were unclear or unfair or both. (They were neither.) But LUR-holders are a powerful group; by definition, the group consists exclusively of people rich enough to own urban LURs, and it certainly includes every powerful family in China. Thus, pressure mounted for free renewals at the end of the term, at least for residential LURs.

In 2007, the authorities granted a teaser: the Property Law was promulgated, and it stated that residential LURs would, at the end of their term, be renewed “automatically.” But it didn’t say what “automatically” meant. As Professor Wang Liming, a member of the drafting team, later admitted, this lack of clarity was no accident; the drafters had deliberately opted for ambiguity.

Why? Think about what automatic, no-fee renewal implies. It means that the 70-year term becomes meaningless; the LUR becomes perpetual. The fact that the land would ultimately revert to the state at the end of the term was what had allowed the government to maintain all along that the LUR regime was consistent with socialism and state ownership of land. If the LUR-holder has the right to the land in perpetuity, that story, already somewhat implausible, becomes impossible to maintain.

On the other hand, if the drafters had stated clearly that renewal required the payment of a fee, LUR-holders would have been outraged. Hence Prof. Wang’s almost comically self-contradictory assurance: “There will be no conditions on extension. As for the term of the extension and the cost, specific measures will be made clear through the promulgation of implementing rules.”

Ten years have since passed. The holders of the first batch of 70-year LURs granted in the mid-1990s are getting itchy. Everyone has been waiting for increased clarity—and by “clarity” they mean “clarity that favors LUR-holders.”

It is that shoe that finally dropped in Li’s statement last month. In answer to a reporter’s question (very possibly planted) about what would happen when the 70-year LURs expired, Li said:

There’s an old saying in China: Economic security brings peace of mind. . . . [T]he term can be renewed, there is no need to apply for renewal, there will be no pre-conditions, and there will be no effect on the ability to buy and sell. Of course, some people may say, “That’s what you say, but is there any legal guarantee?” Let me stress this here: the State Council has already tasked the relevant departments with urgently studying the laws relating to the protection of real estate and coming up with a proposal.

中国有句古话:有恒产者有恒心。. . . 可以续期,不需申请,没有前置条件,也不影响交易。当然,也可能有人说,你们只是说,有法律保障吗?我在这里强调,国务院已经责成相关部门就不动产保护相关法律抓紧研究提出议案。

I don’t see how to read this other than as a promise of perpetual free renewals. This means that people who paid for a 70-year LUR now find themselves with a perpetual LUR: the equivalent of full fee simple ownership. That’s worth noticing.

Commentary, News - Chinese Law | Permalink


Thanks, Don, as always, for updating everyone. I wonder if the granting of renewals without payment or condition will actually weaken property rights in the long term. China's land owners (or "owners") really need a property tax system by which they can finance improvements that benefit their land, but I understand that such taxes are deeply unpopular with LUR holders who are used to the proverbial free lunch. Granting renewals without a big renewal payment was the carrot by which to induce them to accept property taxes. Now that Li Keqiang has given up the carrot for nothing, LUR holders will continue to be stuck in an unsustainable fiscal situation in which cities raise money by surrendering their land for 40-70 years -- a recipe for improvident "build-a-ghost-city" sort of management.

Posted by: Rick Hills | Apr 16, 2017 5:44:36 AM

Thanks, Rick. Yes, looks like property tax is the only way to go now. As you hint, the free renewals should have been presented as part of a package deal that included property taxes. But they have another few decades to solve that problem. My guess is they'll be able to get property taxes up and running before the first non-renewal (so to speak) rolls around.

Posted by: Don Clarke | Apr 17, 2017 12:41:55 PM

The land we own (with relevant state documents) is not really ours. It can be withdrawn anytime under many forms and measures!

Posted by: jigsaw puzzles | May 12, 2021 12:04:15 AM

very good post I love this amazing site keep it up

Posted by: 123betting คาสิโน | Oct 7, 2021 8:50:56 PM

Your articles are a valuable source of information for our investigation. Please continue to submit the required information in order to improve the quality of your article. cookie clicker city

Posted by: mcleanross | Dec 21, 2021 1:18:58 AM

For our investigation, your articles are a valuable source of information. To improve the quality of your article, please continue to submit the required information. cookie clicker city

Posted by: mcleanross | Dec 21, 2021 1:19:29 AM

I am really happy to know this useful website. It gives me a lot of interesting knowledge about everything around especially the content of the above article. subway surfers shell shockers

Posted by: selena | Mar 14, 2022 1:27:42 AM

I do not know what to say really what you share very well and useful to the community, I feel that it makes our community much more developed, thanks slither io

Posted by: slither io | May 17, 2022 8:08:40 PM

Thank you for sharing it with me. I appreciate this piece, and I imagine that the readers are pleased to read it. They will find it useful in gathering knowledge.

Posted by: basketball stars | Aug 17, 2022 9:29:14 PM

Thanks to a number of factors, including improved urban infrastructure and real estate regulations, China is heardle seeing a significant uptick in private land purchases. In some cities, prices have even surpassed those of publicly-held real estate.

Posted by: henny12 | Aug 19, 2022 1:55:08 AM

Have you heard of or participated in Wordle? This is a game that will be of great help to you in every way. wordle website is the most perfect crossword puzzle hidden word game I have ever known, this game has a simple gameplay but it is very difficult for you to find the correct answer. Do you dare to accept the challenge to join Wordle? let's start it now.

Posted by: Duck | Aug 21, 2022 9:28:51 PM

This article analyzing the politics of China is great and it helps me to know more about this country. I enjoyed some of the provisions included in the list of laws. That is something that not every country can do. wordle

Posted by: wordle nyt | Nov 8, 2022 9:27:53 AM

I like your post, and I hope you have many good posts like this to share with the reader.

Posted by: stumble guys | Nov 11, 2022 4:47:49 AM

I enjoy reading your posts, and I wish you would continue to provide readers with quality content.

Posted by: geometry dash | Nov 29, 2022 12:19:05 AM

If the LUR-holder has the right to the land in perpetuity, that story, already somewhat implausible, becomes impossible to maintain.

Posted by: diablo 4 items | Dec 19, 2022 7:49:22 PM

I have read many other blogs, but yours is the only one that has persuaded me, and I hope that you will continue to share more insightful content with readers in the future

Posted by: hurdle | Dec 25, 2022 8:29:16 PM

To choose a casino with a good rating you should check out one of these sites.

Posted by: this link | Dec 27, 2022 5:24:14 PM

Many thanks for the insightful information you provided. It has been difficult for me to come up with numerous queries pertaining to this matter. I shall walk in your footsteps!

Posted by: usps tracking | Dec 28, 2022 1:41:00 AM

Gran trabajo que esperamos se mantenga en el tiempo. Les enviamos un saludo desde nuestro portal de Euromillones para sus seguidores repartidos por el mundo. Comprobar Euromillón

Posted by: Euromillones | Dec 29, 2022 12:57:36 AM

Pinterest Virtual Assistant is a marketing and management tool that helps businesses, bloggers and brands increase their presence on the Pinterest platform.

Posted by: Pinterest Virtual Assistant | Jan 23, 2023 9:28:59 AM

I hope you find this advice to be helpful. Please contact us if you require any additional assistance. quordle game

Posted by: quordle | Jan 30, 2023 7:53:18 PM

Post a comment