Chinese Law Prof Blog

Editor: Donald C. Clarke
George Washington University Law School

Thursday, February 2, 2017

Chinese court enforces Singapore judgment on the basis of reciprocity

Here's a report on an interesting case in which a Chinese court (the Nanjing Intermediate-Level People's Court) enforced a Singapore court judgment.

Under China's civil procedure law, Chinese courts may enforce foreign judgments that are not fundamentally offensive in some way under two circumstances: (1) there is a treaty with the foreign country calling for mutual enforcement of judgments; or (2) on the basis of reciprocity, which has been interpreted to mean that the foreign country has a practice of enforcing Chinese judgments, or at least has done so before.

There is no Singapore-China treaty calling for mutual recognition and enforcement of judgments. The Nanjing court found, however, that in 2014 a Singapore court had enforced a Chinese judgment. On that basis, it decided to recognize and enforce the Singapore judgment (a default judgment against a Chinese corporate defendant).

The report does not claim, and I don't know for a fact, that this is the first foreign judgment Chinese courts have enforced on the basis of reciprocity. (It says it's the first enforcement of a Singapore judgment on that basis.) But I think it's fair to say that such cases are pretty thin on the ground.

The report lists cases where foreign courts have enforced Chinese judgments in the absence of a treaty, suggesting that a basis for reciprocity exists in those cases. The list includes the Robinson Helicopter case, one that I have always thought was a bad example, given that the defendant had already argued in previous US forum non conveniens proceedings that the Chinese legal system was just dandy, and so could hardly be heard to argue otherwise when it came time to enforce a Chinese judgment against it. But if I were trying to enforce a US judgment in a Chinese court, I'd certainly bring it up. To the best of my knowledge, Chinese courts have not yet enforced a contested US money judgment. (I'm attaching those qualifications because they may, for example, have recognized a US divorce decree for some purpose.)

https://lawprofessors.typepad.com/china_law_prof_blog/2017/02/chinese-court-enforces-singapore-judgment-on-the-basis-of-reciprocity.html

Commentary, News - Chinese Law | Permalink

Comments

I have seen reciprocal enforcement of Hong Kong judgments in China. Is Hong Kong foreign in that context?

Posted by: Frankie Leung | Feb 8, 2017 9:36:48 AM

China only enforces judgments of foreign jurisdictions if and when such judgment work in China's favor. Wake up.

Posted by: Frankie Leung | Aug 5, 2017 1:24:51 PM

China only upholds foreign court rulings when and if they are in its best interests. Get up.

Posted by: dordle | Jan 31, 2023 8:19:55 PM

Active codes for free gems, boost, money, rewards

Posted by: roblox codes | Feb 14, 2023 12:49:59 AM

China only upholds international court judgements when it benefits.

Posted by: backrooms | Mar 13, 2023 8:10:54 PM

Your site has generated a lot of genuine attention. I can see why, because you did an excellent job of keeping it engaging.

Posted by: Retro games | Jul 19, 2023 8:53:04 PM

China typically acknowledges foreign court judgments only when they align with its strategic interests. Get informed.

Posted by: iNat Box | Sep 9, 2023 10:07:42 AM

China typically upholds foreign court rulings only when they align with its national interests. Rise and shine.

Posted by: Winlator | Sep 9, 2023 10:08:11 AM

There are some fascinating points in time in this article however I don know if I see all of them middle to heart. There may be some validity but I will take hold opinion until I look into it further. Good article , thanks and we want extra! Added to FeedBurner as well

Posted by: ร้านอาหารอุบล | Oct 5, 2023 3:44:16 AM

yes

Posted by: TG Macro | Nov 2, 2023 10:06:21 AM

The principle of reciprocity, where a foreign judgment may be recognized and enforced if the foreign country has a practice of enforcing Chinese judgments, adds an additional layer to international legal considerations.

Posted by: subway surfers | Jan 24, 2024 12:01:33 AM

Fluxus stands out as a widely used Roblox Executor facilitating gameplay on both PC and mobile platforms.

Posted by: fluxus | Feb 20, 2024 2:47:27 AM

On the other hand, RPCSX serves as specialized software enabling gamers to enjoy PlayStation 4 (PS4) titles on their personal computers (PCs).


Posted by: RPCSX | Feb 20, 2024 2:48:03 AM

Post a comment