Tuesday, April 24, 2018
As I am inclined to do with cases and statutes, I spent some time this week chasing down incorrect definitions of the LLC (correctly defined as a "limited liability company"). I did some perusing of the Code of my home state of West Virginia for incorrect uses of "limited liability corporation," where limited liability company was intended. As I expected, there are multiple errors. Take, for example:
§ 31D-11-1109. Conversion of a domestic corporation to a domestic limited liability company.
. . . .
(i) When a corporation has been converted to a limited liability corporation pursuant to this section, the limited liability company shall, . . . .
This part of the Code uses "limited liability company" correctly throughout this provision, except in this one spot. This should be cleaned up, but it appears to be an error related to repeated use of corporation and company in the same statute (as opposed to a misunderstanding of the concept).
The West Virginia Code has adopted the use of "limited liability corporation" in place of "limited liability company" in a couple definitions provisions, too, which could be a little more problematic.
In the Motor Fuel Excise Tax portion of the Code, we have this, § 11-14C-2. Definitions:
(66) "Person" means an individual, firm, cooperative, association, corporation, limited liability corporation, estate, guardian, executor, administrator, trust, business trust, syndicate, partnership, limited partnership, copartnership, organization, limited liability partnership, joint venture, receiver and trustee in bankruptcy. "Person" also means a club, society or other group or combination acting as a unit, a public body including, but not limited to, this state and any other state and an agency, commissioner, institution, political subdivision or instrumentality of this state or any other state and, also, an officer, employee or member of any of the foregoing who, as an officer, employee or member, is under a duty to perform or is responsible for the performance of an act prescribed by the provisions of this article.
Literally, anyway, LLCs are not defined as persons in this Code section. I am confident that the intent here is quite clear, even if the execution is flawed, but still, this exhaustive list leaves out the West Virginia limited liability company created in WV Code § 31B, the Uniform Limited Liability Company Act.
A similar error occurs in Code Chapter 16, Public Health. Code § 16-2D-2 provides:
(29) “Person” means an individual, trust, estate, partnership, limited liability corporation, committee, corporation, governing body, association and other organizations such as joint-stock companies and insurance companies, a state or a political subdivision or instrumentality thereof or any legal entity recognized by the state.
Here, at least, the catch-all "any legal entity" does include LLCs, but LLCs are still not listed specifically.
This definition language is being repeated in draft legislation, as well, so the error is spreading. See, e.g., House Bill 2873, Budget and Spending Transparency Act ("(c) "Entity" or "recipients" means any corporation, association, union, limited liability corporation, limited liability partnership, legal business entity including nonprofit organizations, grantee, contractor or any county, municipal or other local government entity . . ..")
I am planning to spend some time this summer sending proposed fixes to some key legislators to see if we can get this corrected. Though I concede this is a small fix, it is also an easy fix, and I see no reason not to get it right. Maybe if I do the legwork, it can get done.