Sunday, April 25, 2021
Each week, the Appellate Advocacy Blog Weekly Roundup presents a few tidbits of news and Twitter posts from the past week concerning appellate advocacy. As always, if you see something during the week that you think we should be sure to include, feel free to send a quick note to either (1) Dan Real at DReal@Creighton.edu or on Twitter @Daniel_L_Real or (2) Catharine Du Bois at DuBoisLegalWriting@gmail.com or on Twitter @CLDLegalWriting.
US Supreme Court Opinions and News
The Supreme Court ruled that courts did not need to find that juvenile offenders were beyond hope of rehabilitation to sentence them to life without parole, ending a nearly two-decade trend of expanding protections for young offenders. The ruling, penned by Justice Kavanaugh, finds that “[i]n a case involving an individual who was under 18 when he or she committed a homicide, a state’s discretionary sentencing system is both constitutionally necessary and constitutionally sufficient.” Justice Sotomayor’s dissent argues that the decision departs from Miller v. Alabama, 567 U. S. 460 (2012), and Montgomery v. Louisiana, 577 U. S. 190 (2016), precedent holding that that “a lifetime in prison is a disproportionate sentence for all but the rarest children, those whose crimes reflect ‘irreparable corruption.’” Miller. The dissent states: “[T]he Court attempts to circumvent stare decisis principles by claiming that ‘[t]he Court’s decision today carefully follows both Miller and Montgomery.’ Ante, at 19. The Court is fooling no one. Because I cannot countenance the Court’s abandonment of Miller and Montgomery, I dissent.” See the order and reports from The New York Times, NPR, and The Wall Street Journal.
Appellate Court Opinions and News
The Eleventh Circuit ruled, with regret, against one of Jeffery Epstein’s accusers, holding that she cannot pursue a claim to hold prosecutors accountable for a non-prosecution agreement reached with Epstein in 2007. See the order and reports from The Atlanta Journal-Constitution and Reuters.