Law, Policy, Expertise: Hallmarks of Effective Judicial Review in EU Competition Law

Law, Policy, Expertise: Hallmarks of Effective Judicial Review in EU Competition Law

Pablo Ibáñez Colomo

London School of Economics - Law School

Abstract

This article discusses the techniques – ‘hallmarks’ – that the EU courts have developed to ensure that judicial review remains effective in EU competition law. These hallmarks can be grouped into three main categories. Some of them concern the interpretation of substantive law, namely the definition of legal tests and their consistent use over time. Some, the need for administrative action to rely on the best available evidence (which comprises both reliance on the expert consensus and the careful examination of the economic and legal context). A third category relates to the scrutiny exercised over the policy statements through which the European Commission chooses to constrain its discretion.