Sunday, May 22, 2011

11th Circuit Obstruction Decision - No Evidence That Defendant Knew

Obstruction of justice is a common offense used by prosecutors in white collar matters.  I call it, along with perjury and false statements, "short-cut"offenses - as they usually allow prosecutors to obtain a conviction fairly easily without needing to present a lengthy document case - and white collar cases can be very document intense.  But lately, the government has not been so fortunate in its use of the short-cut approach. Because even if proceeding with a short-cut crime, you still need to prove the case. More importantly, you need to have a case with sufficient evidence of all the elements of the crime.  

The Eleventh Circuit in U.S. v. Dennis Friske, a.k.a. Denny, ruled that the "government failed to introduce sufficient evidence to permit the jury to find that he knew the existence of the forfeiture proceeding."   Bottom line - the case was remanded for the district court to enter an acquittal.  

Although this is not a white collar case, it is an important decision for white collar practitioners as it emphasizes the need to focus on whether the government has the sufficient nexus for an obstruction crime. The court in Friske cites to the Supreme Court decisions in Aguilar and Arthur Andersen in holding that the "government was required to prove that Friske knew of, or at least foresaw, the forfeiture proceeding." Merely acting suspiciously will not be enough.

See also Paul Kish, Federal Criminal Lawyer Blog, Atlanta-based Federal Court of Appeals Reverses Obstruction Conviction Because No Evidence Defendant Aware of the Proceeding He Supposedly Obstructed

(esp)(w/ a hat tip to Linda Friedman Ramirez)

http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/whitecollarcrime_blog/2011/05/11th-circuit-obstruction-decision-no-evidence-that-defendant-knew-.html

Arthur Andersen, Judicial Opinions, Obstruction, Prosecutions | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfae553ef015432794ca8970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference 11th Circuit Obstruction Decision - No Evidence That Defendant Knew :

Comments

Now the things are getting real serious for the white collar crimes prosecutors,

Posted by: Criminal Law Solicitor | Jan 20, 2012 3:03:30 AM

Post a comment