Monday, October 1, 2007

Oscar Wyatt Pleads

Oscar Wyatt and the Oil for Food Program have certainly been a topic in the news (see here). But Wyatt wants to move on and has agreed to a plea that will allow him to do so. According to the media he is agreeing to a guilty plea to one count - conspiracy to commit wire fraud - that will mean he faces a sentence of 18 to 24 months and an 11 million dollar forfeiture. (See Wall St Jrl here, USA Today -AP- here).  Interestingly this plea comes in the middle of his trial (see NYTimes here).

So why might someone plead guilty in the middle of trial?  Here are some possibilities, although this is not to imply that one or any of these apply to this situation -

  • Cost -  The cost of going to trial can be enormous to someone accused of a crime. Ending the process certainly helps in reducing the cost.
  • Risk -  Going to trial is taking a risk.  These days with the federal sentencing guidelines, the risk can be enormous.  Having a plea provides certainty and usually a much lesser sentence absent a not guilty finding.  Hearing the evidence and how that evidence is playing with a jury, may motivate one to avoid additional risk.
  • Moving On - The toll taken psychologically, on someone accused of a crime, is enormous.  Ending the process with a certainty allows for "life after" - which in white collar cases can be important, especially after an extremely long investigation.
  • New Discovery - Unfortunately, not all prosecutors turn over discovery well in advance of trial.  Receiving the discovery can provide a very good reason for wanting to plea, as one now sees the evidence the government has available.
  • Jencks Material - By statute, the government does not have to turn over witnesses statements until after the witness testifies.  Many prosecutors realize the value of turning over this material well in advance of trial.   After all, if the accused sees the evidence against him or herself, there is more likely to be a quick plea. It certainly saves taxpayer money.

(esp)

http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/whitecollarcrime_blog/2007/10/oscar-wyatt-ple.html

Settlement | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfae553ef00e54f025fce8834

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Oscar Wyatt Pleads:

Comments

Oscar Wyatt wants to move on and has agreed to a plea that will allow him to plead guilty to one count - conspiracy to commit wire fraud - a sentence of 18 to 24 months and an 11 million dollar forfeiture.

The man defrauded our country and diverted money to Iraq, an enemy nation of the U.S., and will only serve 18-24 months? He should be tried for treason - he is a traitor to this country.

I'm sick of all these politicians and "fat cats" swindling their way through life with their "it's all about me" attitudes. Our country has always prided itself on what a great society we are. I agree - we are a great society, however, these criminals only give us a bad name to the rest of the world. And the people in power allow them to do it.

When did morality and ethics go out of style? When did doing the right thing become a thing of the past?

Our leaders show no ethics and are not working for the good of this country. They are only working for themselves. Shame on them! And shame on us for allowing them to do it!

Posted by: Susan D | Oct 2, 2007 1:24:11 AM

Having worked for Oscar between 1978 and 2000, I feel he was just acting as any businessman might, and that is to simply pay the additional premium on the oil in order to satisfy the US consumer's desire for cheap energy.

Posted by: Maude | Oct 3, 2007 8:25:40 PM

Post a comment