Securities Law Prof Blog

Editor: Eric C. Chaffee
Univ. of Toledo College of Law

A Member of the Law Professor Blogs Network

Sunday, May 20, 2012

Couture on Actionable Opinions

Opinions Actionable as Securities Fraud, by Wendy Gerwick Couture, University of Idaho College of Law, was recently posted on SSRN.  Here is the abstract:

This Article proposes a new analytical framework to apply to statements of opinion in securities fraud cases. Although statements of opinion form the basis of some of the most cutting-edge securities fraud claims -- such as those asserted against securities analysts and credit rating agencies -- statements of opinion do not fit squarely within the elements of securities fraud. In particular, three issues arise: (1) When is a statement of opinion "false" so as to qualify as a misrepresentation? (2) When is a statement of opinion "material"? (3) And, for that matter, what is the distinction between a statement of fact and a statement of opinion? Courts confronting these issues apply various analytically unsound and inconsistent tests. In response, this Article, drawing on the policy rationales underlying securities fraud claims, case law and scholarly commentary addressing how to apply the elements of securities fraud to statements of opinion, and comparable analyses in the contexts of common law fraud and defamation, proposes a novel approach. First, this Article argues that statements of opinion are only false if both objectively unreasonable and subjectively disbelieved. Second, this Article proposes the following new "evaluation/deduction test" to differentiate statements of opinion from statements of fact: Does the statement express the speaker's evaluation or deduction of facts? Finally, this Article proposes the following new "reasonable implication test" to distinguish opinions that are immaterial as a matter of law from those that are potentially material: Does the opinion reasonably imply an allegedly false, material fact?

http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/securities/2012/05/couture-on-actionable-opinions.html

Law Review Articles | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfae553ef016305ac8934970d

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Couture on Actionable Opinions:

Comments

Post a comment