PropertyProf Blog

Editor: Stephen Clowney
Univ. of Arkansas, Fayetteville

A Member of the Law Professor Blogs Network

Monday, November 5, 2007

Making Apartments Smoke Free: Erosion of Private Property Rights?

The New York Times today reported that an increasing number of U.S. cities have enacted legislation restricting the ability of residents in multi-unit residential buildings to smoke inside their apartments. (It also discussed increased anti-smoking restrictions in public housing units.)

Both public and private efforts to restrict smoking inside these residential buildings seek to minimize the effects of secondhand smoking and protect the rights of residents (who are against smoking) to enjoy their property.  Their efforts, however, consequently impact the rights of property owners.   Although there are private real estate companies that have adopted smoke-free policies in their apartments, others in the real estate industry have complained that smoke-free legislation constitutes "an erosion on private property rights."

In at least one case last year, residents prevailed in a non-payment of rent dispute after they left their apartment because the owner and the building management failed to address their complaints about their neighbor's smoking.  Apparently, secondhand smoke began seeping into their unit. The judge explained that, "secondhand smoke can constitute a breach of the warranty of habitability because under [New York]’s Real Property Law, every written and oral lease contains an implicit warranty that the premises are fit for human habitation and that tenants cannot be subjected to any conditions detrimental to life, health or safety."

Rose Cuison Villazor

[Comments are held for approval so there will be delay in posting.]

http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/property/2007/11/making-apartmen.html

| Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfae553ef00e54f7a84de8833

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Making Apartments Smoke Free: Erosion of Private Property Rights?:

Comments

How long will it be before people are restricted from cooking certain foods in their apartments, simply because the usual suspects complained about the smell of it wafting into their units?! It's not a preposterous question to ask given the Nazi-esque zeal of the anti-smoking crowd, hiz honor Bloomberg with his transfat Gestapo, and of course the left in general. The anti-smoking crowd is an amusing bunch if nothing else. Loathe to invoke an outright ban (it's more fun to tax the hell out of a pack of cigarettes), they're much more secure in creating a permanent class of modern lepers, against whom they can feel self-righteous. And about those taxes...isn't the argument of the anti-smoking crowd that the social demographic of smokers is generally the poor and uneducated? So, what better remedy to heap upon the poor than to tax them. Ah...the amusement never ends.

Bit by bit they surrendered their rights, until nothing was left...will read the history of the fall of rights in America. Orwell's gut must be a mess in the after life from all the laughing.

Posted by: Sam Gompers | Nov 7, 2007 7:22:49 AM

Post a comment