Wednesday, May 2, 2018

California: AG Rejects Requests to Reduce Hospital Charity Care Obligations, Targets Overvaluation of Pharmaceutical Donations

Ag-becerra-officialCalifornia Attorney General Xavier Becerra's office recently addressed two different types of activities relating to charities: the charity care obligations of certain California hospitals, and the valuation of pharmaceutical donations to certain charities.

The charity care issue arose when three California hospitals asked for permission to reduce their existing obligations to provide charity care under agreements entered into with the AG's office when they were participants in a merger or acquisition. The requests were based on changes in the healthcare market, particularly in light of Obamacare. Two of the hospitals are former nonprofit entities that for-profits purchased and now own. Emanuel Medical Center's $3,312,360 charity care obligation (for fiscal year 2016) arose out of a 2014 agreement with the AG relating to its purchase by Doctors Medical Center of Modesto, Inc. See its denial letter. The Mission Community Hospital's $2,424,236 charity care obligation (for fiscal year 2016) arose out of a 2010 agreement with the AG relating to its purchase by Deanco Healthcare LLC. See its denial letter. More details regarding the requests and the AG's consideration of them can be found in reports prepared for the AG's office relating to each request. See EMC Report; MCH Report.

The third hospital is the nonprofit USC Verdugo Hills Hospital, which had a $2,073,564 charity care obligation (for fiscal year 2017) arising out of a 2013 agreement with the AG relating to its purchase by a limited liability company wholly owned by the University of Southern California. See its denial letter. Its situation underlines the fact that such agreements do not only apply to acquisitions by for-profit entities. For more details, see the report prepared for the AG's office.

To make up for missing their required charity care obligations in the fiscal year listed for each of them, the AG is requiring each hospital to make donations to local nonprofits that provide health care services.

Additional coverage: California Healthline, L.A. TimesModern Healthcare.

The pharmaceutical valuation issue relates to cease and desist orders sent by the AG to three charities: Catholic Medical Mission; Food for the Poor; and MAP International. For each charity, the order alleges that the charity reported inaccurately high valuations for contributed pharmaceuticals, leading both to overstating program to administration/fundraising expense ratios in charitable solicitation materials and, for the latter two charities, inaccurate statements in their federal tax (Form 990) and California  (Form RRF-1) filings. The orders direct all three charities to stop including such ratios in their solicitations to California donors, threaten revocation of their charity registration in California, and assess hundreds of thousands of dollars in penalties. A fourth charity, the National Cancer Coalition, dissolved after the AG sought a permanent injunction based on similar issues, according to a report from The Nonprofit Times. The same report notes that the first three charities have issued statements contesting the AG's allegations.

Lloyd Mayer

https://lawprofessors.typepad.com/nonprofit/2018/05/california-ag-rejects-requests-to-reduce-hospital-charity-care-obligations-targets-overvaluation-of-.html

In the News, State – Executive | Permalink

Comments

Post a comment