January 26, 2012
Zolt: "Tax Deductions for Charitable Contributions: Domestic Activities, Foreign Activities or None of the Above"
Eric M. Zolt (UCLA) has posted Tax Deductions for Charitable Contributions: Domestic Activities, Foreign Activities or None of the Above (63 Hastings L.J. 361 (2012) on SSRN. Here is the abstract:
Warren Buffett, Bill Gates, and sixty-seven other billionaires have pledged to give a majority of their wealth for charitable purposes. The total dollar amount of potential funding for charitable activities is staggering. So is the potential loss of tax revenue. Because of past, current, and future tax benefits, U.S. taxpayers have funded and will fund a substantial portion of these charitable activities without any input in how the money is spent. These billionaires are not just being generous with their own money, but with the money of the American people.
Should we allow tax benefits to subsidize charitable activities and allow donors to dictate how funds are spent? This Article seeks to contribute to the debate on the desirability of charitable tax deductions by focusing on a smaller part of the charitable tax world: charitable deductions for foreign assistance. Tax benefits for foreign assistance raise several of the same issues that arise in the purely domestic context, as well as issues that may be less important or absent in the subsidizing of domestic charitable activities.
Recent scholarship has argued for continuing to allow tax benefits to foreign charitable activities, and for extending charitable tax benefits to foreign charities and to for-profit entities engaged in charitable activities. These arguments rest partly on the notion that there is no meaningful way to distinguish these activities or entities from domestic charities engaged in domestic charitable activities. These scholars may be right in arguing for consistent tax treatment for domestic and foreign charitable activity, but they may be wrong in their conclusions. The best approach may be to consider changes to the current charitable-deduction regime for both domestic and foreign charitable activities and to consider other alternatives for the government to provide financial support and other incentives for charitable activities.
TrackBack URL for this entry:
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Zolt: "Tax Deductions for Charitable Contributions: Domestic Activities, Foreign Activities or None of the Above":
You make some very good points. Thank you for your perspective.
Posted by: karenc | Jan 26, 2012 12:09:18 PM
Because of the section 170(d) limitations on deductibility of charitable contributions and the relatively modest annual incomes of Gates and Buffet (modest relative to the size of their charitable contributions), I would be surprised if they get total income tax deductions for their charitable gifts amounting to even one percent of the amounts given. This point, which I discussed with Eric Zolt personally when he delivered a draft of his article at an NYU meeting, is (in my opinion) not well explained in Eric's paper. That, in turn, leads to an exaggerated estimate of tax revenues foregone, since Eric uses the highest marginal tax rate for his estimates whereas I would think that even a one percent rate is probably too high in at least the Gates and Buffet cases.
Posted by: Harvey Dale | Jan 27, 2012 6:34:22 AM