« Walking on Common Ground Tribal/State/Federal Judicial Symposium in Oklahoma | Main | We are EXTREMELY pleased to announce a new program to obtain a Master of Jurisprudence in Indian Law »

April 11, 2011

Federal gov't can NOT prosecute non-Indians for victimless crimes in Indian Country

Here's an interesting twist - in a criminal case over an illegal cockfight conducted on a Kiowa Tribal member's allotment in Oklahoma, the state figured it lacked jurisdiction over the spectators who were arrested.  After all, it was clearly in Indian Country.  So the spectators were charged in federal court.

But in US v. Langford, just announced, the 10th Circuit says that federal jurisdiction over crimes in Indian Country  is "contingent upon the existence of either an Indian victim or perpetrator".......or, in other words, the feds cannot prosecute victimless crimes done by non-Indians in Indian Country.  

HOWEVER, the 10th Circuit specifically said that does NOT leave a jurisdictional void....that, in this instance, "The State of Oklahoma has jurisdiction to prosecute victimless crimes, such as cockfighting, committed in Indian Country by a non-Indian."

You can find the decision posted HERE.

 

twp

April 11, 2011 in Current Affairs, Federal Indian Law and Jurisdictional Matters, General Interest, Reservations, Indian Country and Land Use | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfae553ef014e877329be970d

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Federal gov't can NOT prosecute non-Indians for victimless crimes in Indian Country:

Comments

Maybe Comanche County and Kay County (Oklahoma) will start prosecuting these cases finally.

Posted by: Geronimo | Apr 17, 2011 7:19:40 PM

Post a comment