Monday, June 20, 2011

Some Links to Analysis of the Wal-Mart Opinion

Wal-Mart around the blogs:

Adam Steinman's recap of the case is available on Civil Procedure & Federal Courts Prof Blog.

Sergio Campos analyzes the case on Prawfsblawg.

Lyle Dennison's analysis is on Scotusblog.  Dennison points out the concrete importance of Wal-Mart v. Dukes for mass torts, particularlyPhilip Morris USA, Inc., et al., v. Jackson (docket 10-735) :

That is a case that turns entirely on constitutional questions — a massive class-action lawsuit against the nation’s major cigarette companies in Louisiana state court that resulted in an award of $270 million to a class of former smokers.

Justice Scalia stayed that ruling last September.  The Court has been holding the case until it decided the Wal-Mart case.  It now is expected to take action on that case; its options include granting the case, or sending it back to Louisiana courts to consider the impact of the Wal-Mart decision.   Since the Wal-Mart decision turns mainly upon the meaning of a federal court rule (Rule 23) that does not apply to class-action lawsuits in state court, it is unclear how much specific guidance state courts could take from Monday’s decision.


Class Actions, Resources - Other Blogs of Interest, Tobacco | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Some Links to Analysis of the Wal-Mart Opinion :


Post a comment