Tuesday, February 13, 2007

Walter Olson on Government's Responsibility for Harmful Products

Walter Olson has an interesting article in Reason magazine -- Dangerous When in Power: Does government protect us from hazardous products, or does it put us in harm's way?  Here's an excerpt:

Asbestos exposure has been a genuine public health calamity, having caused much death and disability among exposed workers. Much of the early journalistic coverage, taking its lead from Paul Brodeur's early series in The New Yorker, has treated the episode as a case study in the callousness of private enterprise, which is said to have exposed workers to the lethal mineral for decades until at last brought to heel by the efforts of public-health activists, government regulators, and trial lawyers. That's consistent with the wider conventional view, which treats hazardous products as a sort of standing reproach to capitalism: Businesses foist such products on us in search of profit, the narrative goes, while government protects us from them. And there is much in the asbestos debacle that does reflect discredit on private companies' actions.

Yet the government, our alleged protector, has done much at all levels to promote products later assailed as needlessly unsafe, from tobacco to lead paint, from cheap handguns to Agent Orange. Often the state is at least as aware of the risks as the businesses that distribute the product, and in at least as good a position to control or prevent them. But-shaped and propelled by the incentives provided by our litigation system-our process of organized blame hardly ever puts the government in the dock.



Asbestos, Tobacco | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:


Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Walter Olson on Government's Responsibility for Harmful Products:

» "Dangerous When in Power" from PointOfLaw Forum
A March 2007 Reason article is a must-read for its historical description of how so many mass torts arise from the plaintiffs' bar blaming deep-pocketed private industry for health catastrophes caused by government policy:The wider conventional view [t... [Read More]

Tracked on Feb 14, 2007 6:11:10 AM


Post a comment