Thursday, October 6, 2016

Is it Copyright Infringement if You Copy Another Lawyer’s Brief?

The answer may be yes.

From Patently0:

The court in Newegg Inc. v. Ezra Sutton, PA (CV 15-01395 TJH C.D. Cal. Sept. 2016) (here), faced some interesting facts.  Boiled down, a lawyer representing a co-appellee of Newegg at the Federal Circuit copied a substantial portion of a draft brief written by a lawyer for Newegg, and filed it.

According to news reports, after that, the lawyer withdrew that brief and filed a shorter one which, allegedly, still was based substantially on Newegg’s draft brief.  Newegg then registered copyright for its brief after they were filed, covering both the draft and final brief.  (My mind wonders… if you register copyright on a draft brief, what’s the scope of waiver?) Then Newegg sued the lawyer for copyright infringement.

The original writer, the lawyer for Newegg won. There must have been some bad blood between the lawyers. You can read more here and here. You can access the court opinion here.


| Permalink


Post a comment