Thursday, April 5, 2007

Another Day, Another Disgrace

The appalling disregard for the integrity of the legal profession by the District of Columbia's Board on Professional Responsibility is once again on display. The D.C. Court of Appeals has remanded the case of In re Brian Godette (April 5, 2007). Godette took a fee from a client who was incarcerated at the time of the complaint and abandoned the case. Despite proof that he was aware of the complaint and ensuing charges, he failed to participate in the disciplinary proceedings in any manner. A hearing committee found, at least by implication, that he had evaded service of the disciplinary charges. The Board rejected that finding and recommended a 30 day suspension with no requirement that Godette prove fitness to practice prior to reinstatement. Bar Counsel filed an exception.

The court, over a dissent, rejected the Board's proposed sanction, stating that "it is not the function of the Board... to create hypothetical excuses for [the accused lawyer]." This referred to the Board's speculation that the noises heard from inside the lawyer's home when service was attempted could have been from a minor or "for aught we know, an animal." The court was a little more concerned than its Board about a complete disregard of the duty of a lawyer to cooperate with the disciplinary process.

Unfortunately, as mentioned above, the court remanded the case, which is my experience is a utter waste of time. The Board is ordered to consider whether the evidence established that Godette deliberately evaded service of the charges (there were seven attempts to serve him). I have never seen a remand to the Board that did anything but delay the imposition of sanction and allow them to create a new excuse/explanation for why leniency is appropriate.

When will there be a sufficient public outrage over the actions of the Board (which should be rechristened the Board on Lawyer Forgiveness) to get the court to restructure the disciplinary system to actually focus on protection of the public?  It can't be soon enough.  (Mike Frisch)

http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/legal_profession/2007/04/another_day_ano.html

Bar Discipline & Process | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfae553ef00d8352962fc69e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Another Day, Another Disgrace:

Comments

"ANOTHER DAY, ANOTHER DISGRACE." Nice post but I am not particularly happy that Mike used my own personal mantra, the one I use each morning finding my shakra, as his post title.

Posted by: Childress | Apr 5, 2007 7:22:51 AM

Sorry, Alan. I am reminded of Woody Allen's line about being thrown out of NYU for cheating on his philosophy exam--he looked into the soul of the student sitting next to him.

Posted by: Mike Frisch | Apr 5, 2007 7:49:45 AM

Finding your 'shakra'? Perhaps that's an understandable Freudian slip symptomatic of a sub-conscious conflation of Shakira with chakra. With songs like 'Hips Don't Lie,' and and a two vol. CD, 'Oral Fixation,' one or two chakras readily come to mind....

Posted by: Patrick S. O'Donnell | Apr 5, 2007 8:31:58 AM

Good Freudian point, Patty O. It is even worse than what you suggest if you take into account that my wife's horse is named Shakira. The lesson I have learned is not to use Google as a spell checker, because all you get is a bunch of other morons falsely verifying your own misspelling. Or maybe you spell it with a C in California but we have a different take on it here in the real USA.

Posted by: Childress | Apr 5, 2007 8:41:36 AM

OK: at this end of the bar, weighing in at 235 lbs., it's probably prudent to spell it 'Paddy.'

And having emerged from the womb of oceanic bliss where the Chicago Bears have their training camp, and having spent my 'formative years' in the city that houses the stadium for 'America's (football) team,' I'll take the utopian/dystopian dialectic of the surreal Golden State over 'the real USA' anytime.

Posted by: Patrick S. O'Donnell | Apr 5, 2007 9:17:08 AM

Post a comment