Friday, November 3, 2006

Beale on Tax Ethics and Privilege

Posted by Alan Childress

Linda M. Beale (now at Wayne State, Law) has posted her article on SSRN Law & Socy: Legal Prof. entitled, "Tax Advice Before the Return: The Case for Raising Standards and Denying Evidentiary Privileges."  It was also published earlier this year in the Virginia Tax Review, vol. 25.  The abstract:

 Abusive tax shelters have shone an unappealing light on tax lawyers. Some commentators suggest that these abusive shelters are the work of a small tax shelter bar. This article argues that the same practitioner norms, interpretive approaches, and tax standards that make possible the role of the so-called tax shelter bar in designing mass-marketed shelters also encourage aggressive loophole exploitation in customized tax planning by the regular tax bar.

Recent changes have set the stage for a paradigm shift in tax compliance. A new reportable transaction regime increases transparency. The 2004 Jobs Act's stiffer penalties and heightened standards for penalty protection, at least in the context of reportable transactions that have a significant tax avoidance purpose, move the target towards better compliance. Significant changes to the rules governing practice before the Internal Revenue Service add momentum.

This article argues that the best way to stymie socially wasteful tax planning is to accelerate the paradigm shift. The statutory and ethical standards for positions taken or advised on returns should be raised. A taxpayer should not be able to take a position on a tax return, nor an advisor advise a position, unless it is considered to have a greater than fifty percent likelihood of success on the merits if litigated. To make returns fully transparent and facilitate enforcement, Congress should amend the law to eliminate the applicability to pre-return tax planning advice of the common law attorney-client privilege and work product protection.

Abstracts Highlights - Academic Articles on the Legal Profession, Ethics, Privilege | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Beale on Tax Ethics and Privilege:


Post a comment