October 4, 2006
Saltzburg on death penalty failure--lawyers and courts
posted by Alan Childress
Stephen Saltzburg (George Washington) has posted on SSRN his article, A Grand Slam of Professional Irresponsibility and Judicial Disregard, also published in 34 Hofstra Law Review 783 (2006), detailing a case study of system-wide failure of lawyer and judicial duty in a death penalty case from 1981. The abstract:
Many examples of bad lawyering and indifferent judicial responses to bad lawyering concern those who seek to raise the standards of professional conduct and assure adequate legal representation for all clients. This article discusses one case (a death penalty prosecution of William Charles Payton for rape, murder and attempted murder in 1981) to illustrate just how poor the performance of lawyers can be and how largely indifferent judges often are to such performances. With the defendant's life on the line, it appears that none of the legally trained professionals at trial did what professional standards required of them. The prosecutor acted unprofessionally and disregarded the constitutional right of the defendant in a capital case to rely on mitigation evidence, the defense counsel failed in his responsibility to protect the defendant from the prosecutor's improper conduct, the trial judge failed to correct the prosecutor's conduct or to take measures to assure that conduct did not prejudice the defendant, and the California Supreme Court (and to some extent the United States Supreme Court) pretended that nothing untoward had occurred. The article concludes that the professionals at trial breached their responsibilities: the California Supreme Court failed to appreciate the extent of the breaches and affirmed the resulting death sentence; and federal habeas corpus review under the Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act of 1996 (AEDPA) proved too limited to set aside a sentence that resulted from the breaches.
October 4, 2006 in Abstracts Highlights - Academic Articles on the Legal Profession | Permalink
TrackBack URL for this entry:
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Saltzburg on death penalty failure--lawyers and courts: