Sunday, August 28, 2011

Hirokawa on Zoning and Rezoning under the Change-or-Mistake Rule

Keith H. Hirokawa (Albany) has posted Making Sense of a 'Clear Misunderstanding of the Planning Process': Examining the Relationship Between Zoning and Rezoning Under the Change-or-Mistake Rule. The abstract:

In some states, zoning is marked by the persistence of the so-called “change or mistake rule." In contrast to the traditional deference afforded to local zoning decisions, this rule limits the freedom of local governments to make site-specific zoning amendments by burdening the applicant to justify the rezone with evidence of a mistake or a substantial change in circumstances since the initial zoning designation was adopted. Despite being chastised in the courts and labeled in legal literature as a “clear misunderstanding of the planning process,” the rule has endured for over a half a century. This article explores the criticisms of and justifications for the change or mistake rule in order to identify the understanding that supports its continued application. Specifically, this article argues that the change or mistake rule was intended as a mediator between two fundamental purposes of zoning - maintaining communities that have sufficient flexibility to implement a new community vision, while providing stability and certainty as a planning device.

Looks really interesting. The rule cuts to the heart of the larger, longstanding public administration debate over rational-comprehensive planning versus flexible incremental decision making.

UPDATE: bad link fixed; thanks for the tip!

Matt Festa

http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/land_use/2011/08/hirokawa-on-zoning-and-rezoning-under-the-change-or-mistake-rule.html

History, Local Government, Planning, Property Rights, Scholarship, Zoning | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfae553ef015434e96f36970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Hirokawa on Zoning and Rezoning under the Change-or-Mistake Rule:

Comments

Post a comment