Thursday, June 7, 2007

Rent control and housing stability …

  What’s the effect of rent control laws?  In post-Reagan America, the most common response might be: It constricts the supply the low-cost housing and causes a deterioration in the quality of the same, as landlords avoid money-losing rentals.      

Nycparkavenueold   But a chief purpose of rent control is to provide “housing security,” according to Barnard’s Greg Smithsimon, in an essay on Planetizen.  While economists may fret about the long-term effects of restricting the price of a valuable service, a short-term effect of rent control, the argument goes, is that renters aren’t forced out of their apartments during housing price spikes, such as the bubble that many high-priced American cities have experienced in the past decade.  In New York, where inflation has pulled many units of out rent control, new Governor Eliot Spitzer wants to raise the rent control ceiling to cover units costing more than $2000 (an amount that seemed like a “luxury” rate 10 years ago, but not today). 

  It’s true that rent control provides at least short-term housing security.  And it’s also true that the days of envy-creating “subsidies” to long-term renters in Manhattan or Cambridge are mostly a thing of the past, thanks to reforms of the rent control laws.  But the goal of policy makers should be to ask:  Do the benefits of housing stability outweigh the unwanted incentives of rent control?  Economists may scratch their heads over the concept of the “benefits” of housing stability, and but it’s the question that a good policy maker should have to answer … 

http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/land_use/2007/06/rent_control_an.html

| Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfae553ef00df352036f58833

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Rent control and housing stability …:

Comments

"Housing security," I suppose, is going to be the new buzz phrase used to justify this nonsense.

If you care about housing security, why not offer cash subsidies to those who are being priced out? At least that will avoid future shortages and deterioration of the rental stock.

Posted by: AustinContrarian | Jun 7, 2007 7:12:03 PM

Post a comment