Friday, May 26, 2006

"Overcrowding" masks racism in the exurbs

   What's the biggest housing problem in America's booming exurbs?  From the news in Manassas, Va., outside Washington, the local government apparently thinks that it's overcrowding.  Are there lots of tenements in Manassas, with parents, seven kids, and a grandmother squeezed into a two-room cold-water flat, five stories above a packed street full of push-cart vendors, with only a single tenement house outhouse in a side alley?  No, that was New York in 1910, the last time that Americans worried seriously about overcrowding.  The twist in Manassas is, of course, that the independent city's overcrowding laws are being enforced largely against Hispanic families, who often share a house as a way of coping with the Virginia suburbs' extraordinary housing costs.  Although Manassas recently repealed a restrictive 2005 "family" redefinition, the city still rigorously enforces its overcrowding laws; the city even has an "overcrowding hotline" through which residents can make anonymously tips about neighbors.

   Today's news is that HUD is investigating whether the Manassas law violates the Fair Housing Act by having an unlawfully disproportionate effect on against Hispanics.

   Until I hear that the followers of Jane Addams find 1910-era tenement-level overcrowding in the United States, I argue that governments should abolish their overcrowding laws.  The easy potential for abuse of such laws ("public choice" theory meets the Fair Housing Act) overshadows, in my view, any occasional benefit.

http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/land_use/2006/05/overcrowding_ma.html

| Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfae553ef00d8356292bc69e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference "Overcrowding" masks racism in the exurbs:

Comments

Perhaps the author should own property and live next to these rental situations. It's fun to watch your property value go down, your quality of life degrade, perhaps he even enjoys the exploitation of immigrants and the avarice of the property owners reaping huge profits in undeclared rental income. He must also enjoy the burden these rentals put on the community as a whole education, infrastructure, lost taxes and additional medical care at the tax payers expense. Yes, everyone should look the other way because we do not want to offend anyone specially illegals.

Posted by: nick schetelick | Aug 25, 2008 6:32:37 AM

Post a comment