Monday, April 1, 2013

Clarke on the Gross Confusion Deep in the Heart of Univ. Of Texas S.W. Med. Center v. Nassar

ClarkeBrian S. Clarke (Charlotte School of Law) has posted a short essay on SSRN entitled: The Gross Confusion Deep in the Heart of Univ. Of Texas S.W. Med. Center v. Nassar.

Here's the abstract:

This essay addresses a fundamental issue underlying the Supreme Court’s consideration of Univ. of Texas S.W. Med. Center v. Nassar, namely the parameters of the factual causation standard applicable in disparate treatment cases. This essay also addresses a previously unrecognized area of agreement between the plurality and dissent in Price Waterhouse v. Hopkins that can resolve the factual causation issue underlying Nassar.

The Court’s most recent pronouncement on this issue, in Gross v. FBL Financial Services, has led to confusion as defendants and courts have interpreted Gross to require sole factual causation for the plaintiff to prevail. Yet, sole causation is inherently absurd as every occurrence has a virtually infinite number of factual causes. Nassar provides the Court with a golden opportunity to eliminate the causal confusion that followed Gross and replace it with causal coherence.

To do so, this essay argues, the Court should explicitly adopt the unrecognized factual causation standard from Price Waterhouse: that but-for causation in the disparate treatment context is established when the employer’s consideration of a protected trait was a necessary element of the set of factors that caused the decision.

Very interesting, of course timely, given the prominence this issue has taken on in light of this upcoming U.S. Supreme Court Title VII retaliation case. Check it out!

PS

http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/laborprof_blog/2013/04/clarke-on-the-gross-confusion-deep-in-the-heart-of-univ-of-texas-sw-med-center-v-nassar.html

Employment Discrimination, Scholarship | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfae553ef017ee9e86a58970d

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Clarke on the Gross Confusion Deep in the Heart of Univ. Of Texas S.W. Med. Center v. Nassar:

Comments

This piece is looking for a home in an online law review supplement . . . so, if anyone is inclined to walk it down the hall...

Posted by: Brian Clarke | Apr 4, 2013 6:53:16 PM

Post a comment