Thursday, October 25, 2012

Jury Splits on Political Discrimination Case against Iowa

JusticeYou may have read about Theresa Wagner's lawsuit against the University of Iowa Law School for discrimination against her for her political affiliations. Wagner applied for a position as a tenure-track legal writing professor and was denied. She is currently the assistant director of the writing center, a part time position, not on the tenure track. She also applied for several adjunct positions and was denied. Wagner alleged that the reason was because of her activism in pro-life causes. While the trial court had originally dismissed her claim, the Eight Circuit reinstated it, and it went to trial this month.

Some faculty testified on Wagner's behalf, one of whom has now alleged that he has been retaliated against for doing so. Others testified that the decision was made because of a comment Wagner made at her job talk, suggesting that as a legal writing professor she would not be teaching analysis. The jury came back with a finding for the University on Wagner's First Amendment claim, but deadlocked on her equal protection claim. Wagner has asked for a retrial on both issues. 

This is an interesting case and very much a cause celebre for some conservatives who believe that the vast majority of universities are biased against conservatives. For more on the jury's verdict and the details, see here and here. As an Iowa alum, I'm comforted that a jury found at least partially that the faculty was not motivated by Wagner's politics.Having taught legal research, analysis, and writing, I'm glad that the faculty realized that teaching analysis is part of what legal writing professors do. But finally, having graduated with Wagner, I hope that the University thinks about offering some sort of settlement that would allow everyone to move forward in a constructive way, if that's possible.

MM

http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/laborprof_blog/2012/10/jury-splits-on-political-discrimination-case-against-iowa.html

Employment Discrimination, Public Employment Law, Religion, Scholarship, Teaching | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfae553ef017ee473c3b4970d

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Jury Splits on Political Discrimination Case against Iowa:

Comments

Review a horrible example of a case where the Appeals Court clearly stamps affirmed on Judgments without reading them and examing the record or supporting documents.

Posted by: denie cataldo | Mar 8, 2014 8:46:17 PM

http://iowacasecl110800moorevwoods.weebly.com

Posted by: denie cataldo | Mar 8, 2014 8:46:44 PM

Post a comment