Wednesday, March 21, 2012

Wasserman on Hosanna-Tabor and Jurisdiction

Faculty_WassermanHowardAnd in keeping with the federal courts/Supreme Court theme, Howard Wasserman (Florida International) has a really interesting essay on the Supreme Court's holding in Hosanna-Tabor Lutheran School v. EEOC that the ministerial exception is not jurisdictional in PENNumbra: Prescriptive Jurisdiction, Adjudicative Jurisdiction, and the Ministerial Exception. From the introduction:

Hosanna-Tabor correctly characterized the ministerial exemption as a limitation on the merits of the employment discrimination claim.  I repeatedly argued for this position before the Court entered the mix, including in this Essay, which was written and accepted for publication in October 2011 (before the Court discovered unanimity and thus was able to decide the case fairly quickly).  But the Court’s jurisdictionality footnote was entirely conclusory, failing to explain why the issue controls whether the plaintiff’s allegations entitle him to relief rather than whether the court has power to hear the case.

It thus remains to unpack why the exemption is, in fact, a merits doctrine.  First, doing so demonstrates the correctness of the conclusion in  Hosanna-Tabor, putting to rest any normative dispute on the issue.  Second, mischaracterization of the ministerial exemption resulted from the same category errors that plague characterization of other legal issues; this issue illustrates nicely the routine conflation of jurisdiction and merits and courts’ failure to maintain clean lines between doctrines and underlying concepts. While the Court’s conclu-sion that the exemption is merits-based might be enough to signal lower courts on future jurisdictionality issues, actual analysis and explanation may better enable them to understand and recognize the limits of what goes to jurisdiction and, inversely, the breadth of what goes to substantive merits.

This Essay, I hope, provides that analysis.

I haven't had a chance yet to read the whole thing carefully, but what I've seen so far is a great discussion of an issue vexing to courts, litigants, and scholars alike.

MM

http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/laborprof_blog/2012/03/wasserman-on-hosanna-tabor-and-jurisdiction.html

Commentary, Disability, Employment Discrimination, Religion, Scholarship | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfae553ef0163031db204970d

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Wasserman on Hosanna-Tabor and Jurisdiction:

Comments

Post a comment