Thursday, January 12, 2017
I taught Chae Chan Ping this morning. I continue to find the case compelling reading. The arguments regarding "vast hordes of ... people crowding in upon us" who "will not assimilate" resonate as strongly with today's political rhetoric as they did in the 1880s.
But this post is about teaching The Chinese Exclusion Case.
Specifically, I want to point our dear readers to images, freely available on the interwebs, that you might share with students while teaching this case.
- Chae Chan Ping's registration certificate.
- Are you going to talk about how CCP made it to the Supreme Court? If so, you're talking about the Chinese Six Companies. Here's a portrait of some officers from 1890.
- Justice Field's portrait. The author of CCP. Great to show as you talk about his role in developing the plank of the Democratic national convention urging congress to suppress Chinese labor migration.
- If you talk about the Burlingame Treaty, check out this portrait of Anson Burlingame and the attaches of the Chinese embassy to the President Andrew Johnson at the Executive Mansion. Also, here's a cartoon relevant to Congress' abrogation of that treaty.
- This handbill praising the Chinese Exclusion Act is a fascinating snippet of history.
- If you describe CCP as a labor story, this is a helpful cartoon.
- If you discuss CCP in terms of race (or reference Najia Aarim-Heriot's book Chinese Immigrants, African Americans, and Racial Anxiety in the United States, 1848-82) consider this cartoon.
If you have other images that you use, please share!
Wednesday, January 4, 2017
Detention Nation, like States of Incarceration (discussed yesterday), is a multi-media exhibition that sheds light on immigration detention. It showed at Houston's Station Museum of Contemporary Art in early 2015.
Detention Nation is the project of the art-activist collective Sin Huellas (Without Fingerprints or Without a Trace), a group that takes it name from the practice of removing fingerprints with acid in an effort to avoid the consequences of a prior deportation.
The Texas Observer met with collective members Orlando Lara and Deyadira Arrellano, who spoke about their own experiences with immigration detention.
It's interesting to hear how some things are universal. Lara talks about the lack of medicine in detention and how treating nurses consistently suggest that detainees "drink water." There's a strikingly similar scene in the musical Allegiance where interned Japanese are denied medicine and told to drink water.
I encourage you to check out the Facebook page, which has numerous photos of the exhibit. Any and all would be great additions to the classroom.
And for those of you at big fancy institutions who just might have an on-campus art museum, I'd consider contacting Sin Huellas to see about bringing the exhibit to your campus. It would be a powerful teaching tool.
Tuesday, January 3, 2017
Sarah Lopez is a professor in the University of Texas at Austin School of Architecture. Her work focuses on architectural history within the context of migration.
Of late, Lopez has been examining the architecture of immigrant detention facilities in Texas. It's not an easy project. As Lopez told the Texas Observer, “Studying the architecture of detention is hard... Unless you’re incarcerated or detained, or a warden or a food provider or medical assistant, basically, they don’t want you there.”
mapped the locations of detention centers throughout the state and used Google Earth to create silhouettes of each building’s footprint. The researchers even gained hard-won access to one county-run detention center and built a 3-D model from sketches. Their work marks an important step forward in understanding the physical reality of a clandestine and growing carceral system that prefers to exist just out of reach of the American imagination.
Her class contribution to the exhibition is titled Spatial Stories of Migration and Detention.
Check out this drawing of the La Salle Detention Center by Katie Slusher:
Her drawing is accompanying by these notes:
This layout is drafted from quick sketches and notations created during a tour of La Salle detention center. From an architectural point of view, the detainee living quarters, medical ward, segregation units, and outdoor space were particularly arresting. Aside from outdoor recreation time and voluntary work shifts (for which detainees earn 1 dollar per day), the remainder of a detainee’s average day is spent in a group cell. People with gang affiliations and/or individuals with disabilities are typically placed in smaller capacity or single occupancy rooms. The group cell has exposed bathrooms. Up to 48 men witness each-others’ every move throughout the day. The medical facilities within the detention center contain quarantine cells and a suicide watch room. The suicide watch room is particularly depressing, simply because such a room is necessary. Although used to detain migrants, La Salle has segregation units otherwise known as solitary confinement. Outdoor time for detainees in solitary is restricted to one of the three roof-less rooms extending off the segregation unit cellblock. The segregation unit is equal in size and quality of construction to the suicide watch room, and it is not unlikely that a person may be moved from one to the other.
For all detainees, time spent outside is limited to the federally mandated minimum of one hour per day. Massive barbed wire walls enclose the otherwise barren space.
An excellent project, and a great teaching resource for those of us who are geographically removed from immigration detention facilities.
Monday, December 12, 2016
The Harvard Immigration and Refugee Clinical Program is currently accepting applications for the Albert M. Sacks Clinical Teaching and Advocacy Fellowship. The fellowship provides an opportunity to work on direct representation of individuals applying for asylum and other forms of humanitarian protection, starting in the summer of 2017. The Fellow, who will be housed at Harvard Law School, will assist with the supervision of clinical students and will work closely with experienced attorneys and clinicians at Harvard Law School and Greater Boston Legal Services during the 2017-2018 academic year. The Fellowship will provide teaching opportunities in the form of select lectures in a diverse range of courses; independent writing and scholarship are encouraged. Apologies for duplicative announcements. Interested candidates should apply through the Harvard University Human Resources’ system here.
Saturday, November 5, 2016
The fight over family detention centers is a short (5:30) CNN report that could be used in class to spark conversation about family detention. It helpfully includes still shots of a family detention center (inside and out), closeups of ankle monitoring devices, and video from a community shelter for refugees.
Immprof Denise Gilman (UT) was interviewed by CNN and appears prominently in the video. In the written version of the report, she offers this excellent quote: "Under US asylum law, the way you seek refugee status is to come to the US... That is provided for in the law. That is not law breaking." In the video, she argues that the current carceral setting is not appropriate for "traumatized women and children."
I've got it flagged for my Spring class!
Friday, October 28, 2016
Well, now the musical is coming to you. On Tuesday December 13, it will be aired on big screens (aka in movie theaters) around the nation. Tickets are on sale now.
Here's a clip to whet your appetite. It's called Paradise, and it's a satire about the benefits of living in the Heart Mountain internment camp and the gall of being asked to complete questionnaires designed to suss out the residents' true allegiances.
If you watch the clip, you'll hear them mention Tule Lake (around 1:20). It's where they sent detainees who were determined to be national security threats. Do read the Maurice Roberts piece on his work as a post-war Tule Lake adjudicator. It will really frame the musical for you.
Wednesday, September 14, 2016
Nicole says she was young (20) and 30K in debt; he was a "teeny tiny little Indian man who wanted to stay in America." They "went on interviews" and "took pictures together."
The audience laughs throughout the entire interview.
At the end, Conan says: "You're going to be arrested right after this thing now." Sadly, that's unlikely. Remember Oregon's "first lady" Cylvia Hayes who admitted to marriage fraud? What happened to her? Nothing. As Kevin pointed out then, any prosecution was time barred. And any claim under 18 USC § 1001 would also be time barred.
So, Nicole gets to go on national television and tell an amusing anecdote without repercussions. What are the odds that the man she married is walking away scot-free from this admission? Not great.
Color me appalled.
Tuesday, September 13, 2016
Ireland from space, courtesy of NASA
BBC reporter Simon Maybin recently set out to discover just how many how many Britons might be entitled to Irish citizenship. He'd heard estimates as high as 1-in-4 but, as it turns out, that number tracks a Guinness pool about whether folks had any Irish ancestry or saw themselves as Irish. Since everyone sees themselves as a little bit Irish after a Guinness or two, that wasn't the most accurate assessment of citizenship.
So Maybin called Ireland's Citizens Information service. He learned that he himself was qualified for Irish citizenship because his mother was born in Ireland - despite the fact that she never held an Irish passport herself. Her very birth in Ireland made her a citizen. Maybin further found that "The same rules apply if you have a grandparent born on the island of Ireland." Though, he qualified: "There are a few other subtleties to the rules on getting Irish citizenship, including a change for people born after 2005."
With this broad legal knowledge under his belt, Maybin set out to estimate how many Britons had a parent or grandparent born in Ireland. Some maths later, Maybin concluded that nearly 6.7 million people in the UK might quality for Irish citizenship. That's well in excess of Ireland's 4.6 million population and nearly 10% of Brits.
It's an in-class problem on steroids! Super fun.
Tuesday, August 16, 2016
It can be hard to decide what to assign for your first day of class reading. I humbly submit the following proposal - Psalm by Polish poet Wisława Szymborska.
Oh, the leaky boundaries of man-made states!
How many clouds float past them with impunity;
how much desert sand sifts from one land to another;
how many mountain pebbles tumble onto foreign soil
in provocative hops!
Need I mention every single bird that flies in the face of frontiers
or alights on the roadblock at the border?
A humble robin - still, its tail resides abroad
while its beak stays home. If that weren't enough, it won't stop bobbing!
Among innumerable insects, I'll single out only the ant
between the border guard's left and right boots
blithely ignoring the questions "Where from?" and "Where to?"
Oh, to register in detail, at a glance, the chaos
prevailing on every continent!
Isn't that a privet on the far bank
smuggling its hundred-thousandth leaf across the river?
And who but the octopus, with impudent long arms,
would disrupt the sacred bounds of territorial waters?
And how can we talk of order overall?
when the very placement of the stars
leaves out doubting just what shines for whom?
Not to speak of the fog's reprehensible drifting!
And dust blowing all over the steppes
as if they hadn't been partitioned!
And the voices coasting on obliging airwaves,
that conspiratorial squeaking, those indecipherable mutters!
Only what is human can truly be foreign.
The rest is mixed vegetation, subversive moles, and wind.
Thursday, August 11, 2016
People are guaranteed freedom of movement within the United States pursuant to the privileges and immunities clause of our national constitution. That's not the case everywhere.
As the South China Morning Post reports, China's capitol city of Beijing recently enacted migration rules to keep its exploding population in check.
[A] migrant will be graded according to their contributions to the city and qualifications such as education or age. He or she cannot obtain permanent residency, which is tied to a series of social benefits that migrants do not get, without gaining enough grades.
"Grades" can be achieved by working and paying into social security, having a clean criminal record, having a high educational background, and being under the age of retirement. Benefits from permanent residency include access to better educational opportunities.
Beijing's new rules offer "extra grades" to those willing to move to relocate both work and home to the suburbs.
This article is a keeper for any immprof looking for a comparative perspective on the regulation of internal migration.
Monday, June 20, 2016
Check out this ad from the U.K. Independence Party, which favors the United Kingdom's exit from the European Union (-aka- Brexit).
The Atlantic has thoughtful discussion of the poster and the immigration battle at the heart of Brexit.
Monday, June 6, 2016
Saturday, May 21, 2016
Here's a wonderful little vignette from the NYT: Proposing Marriage to Save Citizenship. The twist? It's the story of a U.S. citizen looking to secure Dutch citizenship in order to stay in the same country as his two children. An immigration official told him he'd have to give up his U.S. citizenship if he wanted to become a Dutch national. Unless he married a Dutch national. And so the author proposed to his then-girlfriend in a cubicle of a government administrator.
That twist just might make this a fabulous reading assignment for students.
Tuesday, May 10, 2016
Monday, May 9, 2016
The Institute for Law Teaching and Learning will be hosting a conference at Washburn University School of Law on June 9-11, 2016. The topic is "Real-World Readiness."
Saturday, May 7, 2016
Wednesday, May 4, 2016
Thursday, April 28, 2016
Monday, April 18, 2016
Oklahoma Photo via the Boston Public Library
You've no doubt spent today glued to the internets scouting for word about United States v. Texas. Sure, it's fun to speculate about what SCOTUS might do, but we'll be waiting on a decision for a few months.
So why not take a fun and distracting trip down history lane with this great piece on Castle Island in New York City.
In 1855, New York City started using Castle Garden (a former fort turned beer garden) as a "state-run immigration portal." As Atlas Obsura describes it, Castle Garden "wasn’t just the main point of entry for immigrants to the U.S., it was the only organized immigration station in the entire country."
Immigrants arriving at Castle Garden were screened for disease and offered treatment. And while it was a place to meet up with family in the New World, it was also a place filled with con artists looking to scam the new arrivals.
One of the most fascinating tidbits in the article is this:
the Yiddish noun kesselgarten, which means “disorder and chaos”, comes directly from a pronunciation of Castle Garden.
Castle Garden remained open until 1890. Thereafter, immigrants were sent to the Barge Office and, later, Ellis Island.
It is now a national monument, and it is definitely on my list to visit the next time AALS rolls around to NYC.
Saturday, March 5, 2016
Trevor Noah is the South African comic who took over for Jon Stewart as host of the Daily Show. He used to be a stand up comic traveling the world and enjoying the strict gaze of immigration officials. Check out this bit:
The first two minutes might be good for use in class to give students the feel of a border interrogation.