Thursday, March 13, 2014

Federal Court Rules Immigrant Detainees Must Be Given Bond Hearings

A federal court has ruled that a class of immigrants detained at the Tacoma-based Northwest Detention Center must be given bond hearings. The court’s decision comes at the same time that hundreds of immigrant detainees are participating in a hunger strike at the facility. U.S. District Court Judge Richard Jones also denied defendants' motion to dismiss the lawsuit brought on behalf of immigrant detainees by the Northwest Immigrant Rights Project and the American Civil Liberties Union, with co-counsel from the Seattle law firm Gibbs Houston Pauw.

The complaint alleges that the defendants – the Department of Justice and the Department of Homeland Security – kept the class members locked up without even the opportunity for a bond hearing, where an immigration judge could determine whether they presented a flight risk or a danger to the community. In the ruling, Judge Jones said it was clear that many of the detainees presented "no risk to their communities and no risk of flight, because some of them have been living in this country for decades and have families and careers. What the government thinks about a law that locks away peaceable family members without release, the court can only guess."

The immigration statute requires people who are taken immediately into immigration custody after serving a sentence for certain crimes be kept locked up without an opportunity for a bond hearing. However, the defendants applied this "mandatory detention" provision even to those who had been permitted to return to their families and community. In his order, Judge Jones made clear that this expansive interpretation violates the plain language of the statute. All three named plaintiffs, two of whom are lawful permanent residents, had been convicted of crimes, and then released to return to their families and employment. Only years later did the Department of Homeland Security arrest them. Instead of affording the plaintiffs an opportunity to demonstrate that they should be permitted to remain with their family and employment during the long immigration proceedings, defendants locked them up without even a bond hearing.

The complaint, Khoury v. Asher, was filed in August 2013 in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington. It challenges the government’s systemic failure in denying bond hearings to this group of individuals, even though over the last 15 years the district court has time and again rejected the government’s position in individual cases.


Current Affairs | Permalink


Post a comment