Friday, February 9, 2007

Immigrant Governator Criticized for Comments About Immigrants and Immigration

In "Latinos lob a few words at governor Leaders label remarks on immigration, heard on tapes, as offensive," Anna Gorman in the L.A. Times (here) reports that California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's off-the-cuff comments in recently released audio recordings about illegal immigration and the unwillingness of Mexicans to assimilate into American society have drawn angry responses this week from Latino community and political leaders. "I made an effort," the Austrian-born Schwarzenegger told aides last April in conversations that touched on assimilation. "But the Mexicans don't make that effort." The governor also used an expletive to disparage the 1986 federal law that granted asylum to more than 2 million illegal immigrants.

A recent study (here) discussed in the Christian Science Monitor also touches on issues of immigrant assimilation.  US workers may be significantly less literate in 2030 than they are today. The reason: Most baby boomers will be retiring and a large wave of less-educated immigrants will be moving into the workforce. This downward shift in reading and math skills suggests a huge challenge for educators and policymakers in the future, according to a new report from the Educational Testing Service (ETS).

Restrictionists could read this study as supporting immigration restrictions and increased border enforcement.  However, a more sensible response to the report, as well as the Governor's fears about lack of immigrant assimilation, would be to facilitate integration and assimilation, as suggested in the 1990s by the U.S. Commission on Immigration Reform headed by Congresswoman Barbara Jordan.  Investment, for example, in expanded English as a Second Language programs, which often are overenrolled in many cities, makes more sense than spending billions on border enforcement measures with little, if any, likelihood of success.


| Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Immigrant Governator Criticized for Comments About Immigrants and Immigration:


RE: Christian Science Monitor

Assimilation of millions of first generation Latin Americans will not make up for the legacy their limited educations brings with them. The fact that they understand almost no English gives them an additional handicap.

The educators of our society tell us to educate ourselves, to stay in school, because they are well aware that by the time we reach adulthood our ability of to make up for the loss of our early years is limited, mainly due to the immediate need to earn a living. This is how the current wave of illegal alien Latin Americans find themselves. It's a fact that people with little education are very limited in their upward mobility. These are the people who will most likely depend upon meager Social Security for their retirement. These are the people whose children will, for the most part, not afford a college education. Their earning class, coupled with their typically large families will likely make them dependent upon supplemental support from the the federal government, or more precisely, you and I as taxpayers. Historically, poverty breeds poverty, so this will pertain to more than one generation.

Immigration without sound consideration for the economic impacts and social goals of our nation is folly, but this is what you would impose upon us.

Posted by: George | Feb 9, 2007 11:05:42 AM

Post a comment