HealthLawProf Blog

Editor: Katharine Van Tassel
Concordia University School of Law

Thursday, September 7, 2006

Disability Convention: US Unlikely to Sign

An interesting article in the New Standard reports that United States has played a large role in influencing the new Convention on the Rights of People with Disabilities but doesn't want to sign on to it.  The article states:

The United Nations has been working on the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities since December 2001, when it formed ad-hoc committees to study the issue. Five years later, UN delegates are in a final week of negotiations over provisions of the draft convention, which aims to promote respect, autonomy, non-discrimination, inclusion, accessibility and equal opportunity for people with disabilities.

"Our view is that the US actually already has in existence on the federal level, the state level and the local level a very good framework of laws and practices to assist citizens with disabilities," Paul Denig, with the US State Department, told The NewStandard, referring to the 1990 Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). "In our view, this treaty would not add to that." . . .

Silvia Yee, staff attorney at the California-based Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, said it is important for the US to sign the treaty to show support for the world’s 650 million people who have disabilities, many of whom currently have few rights. . . .

"Though the US refuses to sign the convention, it has been heavily involved in negotiations on many of the draft’s provisions, including end of life issues; parental decision-making regarding children; the prohibition against involuntary sterilization; and informed consent for genetic testing, medical research and scientific experimentation.

Yee said she does not believe US opposition to signing the convention has anything to do with the issue of disability rights.

"I think it’s because the US just doesn’t necessarily believe in the international treaty and rights monitoring model," she speculated. "I think it has always been very staunch about the sovereignty of the United States and not necessarily in favor of any giving up of that sovereignty in terms of recognizing international bodies."

According to the UN Secretariat Thomas Schindlmayr, only 45 countries have anti-discrimination legislation protecting disabled people. The General Assembly’s ad-hoc committee is scheduled to wrap up negotiations today.

| Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Disability Convention: US Unlikely to Sign:


Post a comment