Thursday, August 21, 2014

Women Judges Can't Decide Sports Cases

Local Mom Decides Important Sports Case.  Sportcasters have discounted federal judge Claudia Wilken who decided O'Bannon v. NCAA, the landmark case that challenged the NCAA’s longstanding treatment of its college athletes, by describing her as "local PTA mom."   Its not her Stanford or Berkeley education nor decades of legal and judicial experience that informed her decision, but her motherly work on the PTA.

[NYT Sportswriter] writes that her “decision [in O’Bannon] may be interpreted much the way her advice at school meetings often was: Let’s work it out, through dialogue and compromise.” If decades of legal experience can’t explain what made Wilken capable of presiding over the O'Bannon case, perhaps her stint in the PTA will.

http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/gender_law/2014/08/women-judges-cant-decide-sports-cases.html

Sports | Permalink

Comments

Post a comment