EvidenceProf Blog

Editor: Colin Miller
Univ. of South Carolina School of Law

A Member of the Law Professor Blogs Network

Tuesday, October 8, 2013

My New Essay -- No Explanation Required?: A Reply to Jeffrey Bellin’s eHearsay

Today, I posted my new essay, No Explanation Required?: A Reply to Jeffrey Bellin's eHearsay, on SSRN. The essay is a solicited response to eHearsay, by co-blogger Jeff Bellin. Here is the abstract:

You see why I tell you I ain’t want to be no damn juror. Some dude just come by my house and tell me he going pay me money to say not guilty. Now I don’t know what to do, because if I tell the judge they’re going to know it’s me.

I know, right. Now I scared because I don’t want them to do anything to me or [my daughter][. . .] * * *

The above were text messages sent by a juror to her sister after Ikim Blackett allegedly threatened and then tried to bribe her in an attempt to convince her to find one of several defendants “not guilty” of various drug crimes. At Blackett’s ensuing trial for jury bribery, the juror testified that, while she was on her front porch, Blackett approached her and mentioned the word “nitroglycerin.” The juror then “asked Blackett what ‘nitroglycerin’ meant and he responded ‘not guilty.’” When this threat fell on deaf ears, Blackett offered the juror $1,500 in exchange for her vote. After again declining, the juror went to her bedroom and sent the above text messages.

Should the text messages have been admissible because the juror took the witness stand and testified at trial? If the juror were “unavailable” at trial, should the text messages have been admissible? According to Professor Jeffrey Bellin’s article, eHearsay, the answer to both questions is “yes” as he crafts hearsay rules that cover both situations. This paper agrees with Professor Bellin on the first question but disagrees with him on the second.

-CM

http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/evidenceprof/2013/10/my-new-essay-no-explanation-required-a-reply-to-jeffrey-bellins-ehearsay.html

| Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfae553ef019affdbb747970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference My New Essay -- No Explanation Required?: A Reply to Jeffrey Bellin’s eHearsay:

Comments

Post a comment