EvidenceProf Blog

Editor: Colin Miller
Univ. of South Carolina School of Law

A Member of the Law Professor Blogs Network

Wednesday, November 7, 2007

Hiding the Ball: Tim Masters Presents Brady Claims in Peggy Hettrick Murder Case

In 1999, Tim Masters was convicted of murder in connection with the stabbing death of Peggy Hettrick in 1987.  Masters, who was 15 years-old at the time of the murder, has now made a bid for a new trial, claiming that he received the ineffective assistance of counsel at trial and that the prosecution failed to disclose material exculpatory evidence to him.

You can find the full details of the case in this Denver Post article, but here are the basics.  Early one morning in 1987, 37 year-old Peggy Hettrick was discovered dead in a field with several knife wounds; her left nipple and areola had been carefully removed, and the front of her body had been wiped clean of blood.  Officers went door-to-door to see whether anyone knew about the murder, and they eventually came to Clyde Masters' house, which was 100 feet south of Hettrick's body.  Clyde told the officers that his son, Tim, regularly walked through the field where the body was found on his way to school and suggested that he may have seen something.  When officers later questioned Tim, he admitted to seeing Hettrick's body but claimed that he didn't report it because he thought that it was a mannequin and/or that a prank was being played upon him.

The officers later learned that in his school notebooks Tim sketched dinosaurs with arrows through them, gruesome war scenes, knife wounds, and horror films such as "Nightmare on Elm Street."  From this evidence and other information, the state somehow developed the theory that Tim was a "psycho killer" with deviant sexual fantasies. 

It was determined that Tim's mother died almost four years to the day before Hettrick's death, and officers came to the bizarre conclusion that because both women had red hair, Hettrick's murder was an anniversary killing and that one year after Hettrick's death, Tim would go "beserk" and revisit either the murder scene or Hettrick's grave.  Police thus set up a "sting" operation where they shadowed Tim a year after Hettrick's death, but he visited neither the crime scene nor the grave.  The prosecution, however, neither disclosed this failed "sting" to Tim Masters, nor did they disclose:

     -evidence relating to alternate suspect Dr. Richard Hammond and their theory that the sexual mutilation of Hettrick was likely done by a skilled expert (echoes of Jack the Ripper), or

     -evidence that police falsley told a reporter that they were close to making an arrest, delivered the paper where the reporter reported this story to the Masters house, and then suggested that Hettrick's killer would hoard stories about the case, all as part of an (unsuccessful) attempt to get Masters to confess.

Pursuant to the Supreme Court's opinion in Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963), a new trial is warranted when the prosecution fails to timely disclose to the defendant material exceulpatory evidence.  Evidence is "material" when there is a reasonable probability that its timely disclosure would have changed the outcome at trial.  While it's difficult to say whether the undisclosed evidence should be deemed "material" without knowing all of the other evidence in the case, it is important to note that courts before have found Brady violations when prosecutors have failed to disclose evidence of alternate suspects, see, e.g., Commonwealth v. Bussell, 226 S.W.3d 96 (Ky. 2007), and important evidence relating to "stings," see, e.g., Banks v. United States, 920 F.Supp. 688 (E.D. Va. 1996).

-CM   

http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/evidenceprof/2007/11/in-1999-tim-mas.html

| Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfae553ef00e54f7cc0b28833

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Hiding the Ball: Tim Masters Presents Brady Claims in Peggy Hettrick Murder Case:

Comments

I'm not an attorney but I've been following this mess for years and have been told that an article I wrote is a pretty good overview of the basics in this very complicated case that stretches over 20 years.

http://earthblog.net/eb-articles/hartman27.html

Best of all possible regards,
Pat Hartman

Posted by: Pat Hartman | Nov 7, 2007 4:54:34 PM

A new turn in this case was just announced. DNA tests have excluded Masters and point to another suspect.

http://www.cnn.com/2008/CRIME/01/18/masters/

Posted by: A Addams | Jan 19, 2008 12:08:40 AM

The interview Cop Should be Broght upon charges for throwing this guy's Life away

Posted by: John | Jan 22, 2008 8:11:37 AM

I knew Tim in the Navy while serving in China Lake. He was always a quiet, shy kind of person who never really had much to say about anything. Though I did see him laugh once in a while there was a feeling about him that he was a sad person. I never knew about this cloud hanging over his head and thought he was just a shy and sad type of person. I went to his home in Ridgecrest CA to look at some puppies that his dog had just had. He wanted his puppies to have a home and didn't want to send them to the pound, so he was trying really hard to get people to take them. I stayed at his house and tried to talk to him a bit but he just didn't have anything to say. He was seemingly unimpressed with me so I left. Had I known about the events in his life I would have understood why he was so quiet, shy, and seemed so sad. I am glad to say though he may have been stoic I do remember seeing him laugh a few times, though his usual sadness quickly returned.

I wish him all the best in life and hopefully soon he will find that wife he deserves to be his partner in life. I'm so glad that there were some people who believed in him to lend him a hand when the justice system turned its backs.

Good luck Tim,
Jennifer

Posted by: Jenn | Mar 18, 2009 11:05:20 PM

Post a comment