Friday, January 17, 2014

The Obama Administration's Misunderstanding About the Connection Between Higher Education and K-12 Diversity

Civil Rights advocates have been less than enamoured with the Obama administration's approach to diversity in K-12 education, but credit goes to the administration on higher education.  DOJ's briefs in Fisher v. Texas--before the Supreme Court and on remand--have been forceful and creative in their defense of affirmative action.  Yesterday, the administration continued to emphasize access to higher education as one of its top priorities.  The Los Angeles Times billed yesterday's forum as an effort to "encourage economic diversity in higher education."  

The administrations efforts are worthy of applause for their symbolism, but they overlook the crucial practical link between integration in K-12 and higher education access.  One of the most significant factors in higher education attainment is not higher education policy, but the high school a student went to and the peer influences experienced there.  Middle class schools have a culture and expectation of higher education attainment that does not require significant prodding from the outside.  Minority students are disproportionately excluded from those schools and, instead, attend schools where graduating from high school is not even necessarily the dominant expectation.  In these schools, selling students on college and making it a realistic goal is more of an uphill battle and requires outside influences, which are not nearly as effective (although surely worth the effort).  In short, if the administration were serious about higher education access, it would think more seriously about its K-12 integration policy.

http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/education_law/2014/01/the-obama-administrations-misunderstanding-about-the-connection-between-higher-education-and-k-12-di.html

Federal policy, Racial Integration and Diversity | Permalink

Comments

Post a comment