Thursday, January 30, 2014

School Reportedly Suspends Student for His "Gay Lifestyle"

Robert Marucci, an 18-year-old high school student, in Florida was allegedly suspended for his participation in gay pornography.  Marruci states that he started working in the industry to help his mother pay the bills.  Apparently, the family has fallen on hard times and his work does not violate any law.  Regardless, when other students at his school learned of his work, he indicates he was bullied and threatened.  If the school knew of and did not respond to this bullying, it violated Title IX's prohibitions on sexual harassment.  See Davis v. Monroe County, 526 U.S. 629 (1999). Marucci's mother says that this is exactly what the school did.  Strike one against the school.

What the school did do was suspend Marucci for ten days.  His mother says he was "expelled due to his explicit lifestyle career.”  The school indicates that it suspended him for "possible threats" he had made.  The devil is in the detail, but "possible threats" sounds vague.  If it is only "possible" that he has made threats to other students, the school lacks a basis to suspend him.  At best, if the threats were extremely serious, the school could have removed him temporarily to investigate (per a narrow exception in Goss v. Lopez).  This does not appear to be the school's claim.  Sounds like strike two against the school.  

If the school, in fact, removed him for his off-campus lifestyle choice, it may have engaged in another Title IX violation, as well as Free Speech.  Strike three (and four, I suppose). 

 

http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/education_law/2014/01/school-reportedly-suspends-student-for-his-gay-lifestyle.html

Bullying and Harassment, Discipline, Gender | Permalink

Comments

Post a comment