CrimProf Blog

Editor: Kevin Cole
Univ. of San Diego School of Law

Tuesday, December 5, 2017

"Microsoft Challenged the Wrong Law. Now What?"

Orin Kerr has this post at LawFare. In part:

The Supreme Court recently agreed to hear an important electronic privacy case, United States v. Microsoft, on whether Microsoft has to comply with a United States search warrant for email stored by Microsoft on a server in Ireland. I’m going to explain in this post why I think the case comes to the court with a major problem. Specifically, Microsoft brought its challenge under the wrong statute. Microsoft is challenging its compliance under the Stored Communications Act (SCA), but it should be challenging its compliance under the All Writs Act (AWA).

The difference is important. Microsoft's focus on the Stored Communications Act leaves the Supreme Court with no good options. From a perspective of policy, you wouldn't want either rule that Microsoft's framing sets up. Had the challenge been brought under the All Writs Act, however, the court could use traditional interpretive principles to craft a sensible rule in the case. This post explains how.

| Permalink


Post a comment