« Objections to NYPD database holding information on those frisked and released | Main | Top-Ten Recent SSRN Downloads »

March 13, 2010

Back to the future on sentencing disparity

Doug Berman at Sentencing Law and Policy has an interesting post on the troubling implications of a recently released report by the U.S. Sentencing Commission indicating that the post-Booker increase in sentencing discretion has led to an increased correlation between sentence length and "the demographic characteristics" of some offenders. Doug's preliminary thought:

Though I will need to review this new report and its data closely before developing a detailing reaction to these findings, I will start by suggesting that my own anecdotal post-Bookerexperiences suggest that economic realities and the disparate efforts of prosecutors and defense counsel may account for worrisome disparities more than the determinations of sentencing judges.  I fear there my be some systematic and structural biases, often influenced by socio-economic realities, that can result in prosecutors charging and bargaining a bit harder on certain types of offenders and that can result in defense counsel developing better mitigating arguments for certain types of offenders. 

March 13, 2010 | Permalink

Comments

Post a comment