CrimProf Blog

Editor: Kevin Cole
Univ. of San Diego School of Law

Monday, January 18, 2010

Leo and Gould on Wrongful Convictions and Social Science

Leo richard Richard A. Leo (Univrsity of San Francisco - School of Law; pictured) and Jon B. Gould have posted Studying Wrongful Convictions: Learning from Social Science (Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law, Vol. 7, 2009) on SSRN. Here is the abstract:

There has been an explosion of legal scholarship on wrongful convictions in the last decade, reflecting a growing concern about the problem of actual innocence in the criminal justice system. Yet criminal law and procedure scholars have engaged in relatively little dialogue or collaboration on this topic with criminologists. In this article, we use the empirical study of wrongful convictions to illustrate what criminological approaches – or, more broadly, social science methods – can teach legal scholars. After briefly examining the history of wrongful conviction scholarship, we discuss the limits of the (primarily) narrative methodology of legal scholarship on wrongful convictions. We argue that social scientific methods allow for more precise and accurate depictions of the multifactorial and complex nature of causation in wrongful conviction cases. In the main body of this article, we discuss and illustrate several social science approaches to the study of wrongful conviction: aggregated case studies, matched comparison samples, and path analysis. We argue these methods would help criminal law and procedure scholars to better understand the causes, characteristics, and consequences of wrongful convictions than a purely narrative approach. Finally, we offer concluding thoughts about improving the dialogue between criminal law and criminology on the subject of wrongful conviction.

| Permalink


Mr. Leo,
Great Piece. Please consider letting the team know if you or Mr. Gould would be interested in participating in an online interview regarding the causes & effects of wrongful convictions. Note: We are conducting textual Qs & As type interviews at this time but plan to implement video at a later date. Thanks.

Posted by: The Team | Jan 19, 2010 10:47:08 AM

Post a comment