CrimProf Blog

Editor: Kevin Cole
Univ. of San Diego School of Law

Monday, September 1, 2008

Criminal Law, Public Health and HIV Transmission

A number of cases have been reported in which people living with HIV have been

criminally charged for a variety of acts that transmit HIV or risk transmission. In some cases,

criminal charges have been laid for conduct that is merely perceived as risking transmission,

sometimes with very harsh penalties imposed. Some jurisdictions have moved to enact or

amend legislation specifically to address such conduct. The issue has also received public

and academic commentary.

These developments raise the question of whether criminal laws and prosecutions

represent sound policy responses to conduct that carries the risk of HIV transmission.

Individual cases, and accompanying media coverage, may prompt public calls for such a

response. But there are few simple solutions to such a complex problem, and a rush to

legislate should be avoided in favour of careful consideration. To assist in the development

of sound public policy, this paper:

proposes some principles that should guide thinking about, and development of, law

and policy on the question of criminal law and HIV/AIDS;

identifies a number of public policy considerations that states should take into account

when making decisions about the use of the criminal law;

considers the alternative to criminalization presented by public health laws;

discusses if and how the criminal law might be justifiably applied, considering

in particular:

(a) whether HIV-specific legislation is warranted;

(b) which acts that transmit HIV or carry the risk of transmission could be subject

to criminal sanctions;

(c) what degree of mental culpability should be required to impose criminal sanctions;

concludes with recommendations to governments, police, prosecutors, judges and

public health authorities regarding the appropriate use of criminal sanctions and

coercive public health measures. [Mark Godsey]

Continue Reading "Criminal Law, Public Health and HIV Transmission"

Criminal Law | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Criminal Law, Public Health and HIV Transmission:


Post a comment