April 7, 2006
New Article Spotlight: "Eggshell" Victims, Private Precautions, and the Societal Benefits of Shifting Crime
UC Davis CrimProf Robert Mikos has posted "Eggshell" Victims, Private Precautions, and the Societal Benefits of Shifting Crime, 105 Mich. L. Rev. ___ (forthcoming 2006), on SSRN.
The abstract reads: Individuals spend billions of dollars every year on precautions to protect themselves from crime. Yet the legal academy has criticized many private precautions because they merely shift crime onto other, less guarded citizens, rather than reduce crime. The conventional wisdom likens such precaution-taking to rent-seeking: citizens spend resources to shift crime losses onto other victims, without reducing the size of those losses to society. The result is an unambiguous reduction in social welfare. This Article argues that the conventional wisdom is flawed because it overlooks how the law systematically understates the harms suffered by some victims of crime, first, by ignoring some types of harm altogether in grading and sentencing decisions, and second, by ignoring wide disparities in the amount of harm caused in individual cases. It follows that the same “crime”, as defined by the law, may inflict significantly different amounts of harm on different victims, and by aggregation, on society. Thus it cannot be safely assumed that displacing a given crime from one citizen to the next is necessarily wasteful, from a social point of view. Indeed, this Article argues that shifting crime may be beneficial to society, from an economic point of view, since eggshell victims - those who are harmed more by crime - tend to take more precautions. The implication is that private crime fighting efforts that displace crime - universally criticized in the literature - may be more socially useful than previously acknowledged. The Article discusses the implications for the ongoing debates over the regulation of precaution-taking.
TrackBack URL for this entry:
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference New Article Spotlight: "Eggshell" Victims, Private Precautions, and the Societal Benefits of Shifting Crime:
I like displacement.
When people talk about displacement, they often ignore an element I call friction (there may be a more academically accepted term, but I'm not familiar with it.). That is, if you make it more inconvenient for some people to commit a crime, some will consider it too much effort and not bother. Making things INCONVENIENT is a huge tool in changing people's behavior.
Posted by: Leo | Apr 7, 2006 11:37:52 PM