CrimProf Blog

Editor: Kevin Cole
Univ. of San Diego School of Law

Monday, November 22, 2004

Death Sentence Rates and County Demographics: An Empirical Study

The above-titled paper by Cornell Prof Theodore Eisenberg recently posted on SSRN addresses the question:  "Why do black defendant-black victim cases receive by far the lowest rate of death sentences?"  The abstract states:

"One hypothesis is that prosecutors devalue black victims' lives and do not regard black-victim murders as seriously as white victim murders. A second hypothesis, one that need not preclude the first, posits that black communities' aversion to the death penalty leads prosecutors to seek it less, or juries to impose it less, in minority communities. The first view represents a version of old-fashioned stereotypical racism. The second hypothesis could be regarded as democracy at work. Communities more hostile to the death penalty elect officials and process criminal cases in a manner that reflects local community values. This Article finds that, in addition to the number of murders, three other demographic factors influence the death sentence rate at the county level. The rate of death sentences decreases as a county's black population percent increases, as a county's per capita income increases, and as a county's homicide rate increases."  [Mark Godsey]

| Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Death Sentence Rates and County Demographics: An Empirical Study:


Post a comment