ContractsProf Blog

Editor: D. A. Jeremy Telman
Valparaiso Univ. Law School

A Member of the Law Professor Blogs Network

Tuesday, October 2, 2012

Lawyer Who Forgets About "Offeror is King" Wins, Then Loses, Contest

CrownWhile teaching the concept of "offeror is king" this semester, I said something like, "I wish I had a crown.  One of you should bring me a crown!  There might be some participation points in it for you if you do."  (It sounded less entitled than that quote but you get the point.)  Shortly thereafter, two students brought me a crown--one from Burger King (of course!) and one from a party supply store.  The first one was just slipped under my door but the second one had "terms of acceptance" attached.  The terms stated that I had to use the crown in class and not disclose the student's name in order to accept.  I did both, and my acceptance was deemed substantively valid and timely by the entire class.  

Another student recently alerted me to a New York Times story about a lawyer victimized by the "offeror is king" concept.  The lawyer, Theodore Scott, reportedly produced a winning video and essay in response to a contest offer from Gold Peak Tea.  The contest winner would receive  $100,000 to take a year off and enjoy life (presumably over some tea).  However, after Mr. Scott's video received the highest number of votes and was declared the grand prize winner, Gold Peak Tea had a change of heart.  Apparently, Mr. Scott had requested votes for his contest entry via a crowdsourcing website on which people, well, request votes for things like this.  Gold Peak Tea took the position that Mr. Scott's online plea for votes violated the contest rules.  Because Mr. Scott accepted in a way other than that specified by the offeror, there was no deal, and a different winner was selected. 

As an interesting side note, many folks appear to be bombarding Gold Peak Tea's Facebook page with comments supporting Mr. Scott, the original winner.  The Facebook response from Gold Peak Tea reads as follows: 

    "Gold Peak appreciates input from the community on our Facebook page. The Take the Year Off     program was created to reward a Gold Peak Tea fan with the opportunity to refresh, renew and     refocus. By devoting more time to his three special needs children and bettering his community with     the development of a local equine therapy program, Michael Simpson will take the year off in a     deserving fashion. We’d like to address some of the feedback shared about the Take the Year Off         promotion and how the winner was determined:

 

Michael Simpson was declared the winner after we fully vetted his submission to ensure all content was in adherence with Official Contest Rules (http://CokeURL.com/TTYORules).

Unfortunately, Theodore Scott was disqualified when it was determined during the verification process that he had attempted to inappropriately induce members of the public to vote for his submission, a violation of Official Contest Rules (http://CokeURL.com/TTYORules).

The House Rules for the Gold Peak Tea Facebook page state that users will not “publish, post, distribute or disseminate any defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, misleading or unlawful material or information.” Certain posts addressing the Take the Year Off promotion do not abide by these Rules and have been removed (http://CokeURL.com/HouseRules)."

Gold Peak hopes the members of this community will join us in wishing Michael Simpson well in his year off."

Perhaps the ultimate message, then, is not "offeror is king" but, rather, "read the fine print."

[Heidi R. Anderson, hat tip to Ly Tran]

 

 

 

http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/contractsprof_blog/2012/10/lawyer-who-forgets-about-offeror-is-king-wins-then-loses-contest.html

Current Affairs, Games, In the News, Teaching | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfae553ef017ee3eb49f3970d

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Lawyer Who Forgets About "Offeror is King" Wins, Then Loses, Contest:

Comments

Post a comment