ContractsProf Blog

Editor: Myanna Dellinger
University of South Dakota School of Law

Wednesday, March 21, 2012

NY Times "Ethicist" on Charitable Subscriptions

CardozoWe crossed virtual swords in the past with The New York Times' original ethicist Randy Cohen.  We reported on harassing him with angry letters denouncing his conflation of law and ethics.  Mr. Cohen saw the error of his ways and apologized sub silentio in a later column on which we reported here.

Now the Times' "The Ethicist" column is authored by Ariel Kaminer who is much better attuned to the distinction between ethics and law, as evidence in this week's column.  Two weeks ago, a correspondent asked Ms. Kaminer if it was permissible to renege on a pledge to a university after learning that the university engages in dubious labor practices.  Ms. Kaminer responded in her column that revoking a pledge is permissible because, "A pledge is a good-faith statement of intent, not a contract written in blood."  This week, Kaminer acknowledges a comment from a Palo Alto attorney, Geoff Rapoport, informing her that charitable pledges are enforceable because the law assumes that they have been relied.on, so her advice could expose her correspondent to a lawsuit.  Mr. Rapoport acknowledged that Ms. Kaminer is in the business of giving ethical advice, and that the ethcial and the legal "only sometimes overlap."  She agreed but regretted not having noted the possibility of legal liability.

Ms. Kaminer is extremeely conscientious to do so.  As she observes, while a suit is possible, it is not likely.  We note that, as the picture on the left indicates, the doctrine in question derives from Judge Cardozo's opinion in Allegheny College, about which we have posted in the past, the holding of which can be found summarized in Section 90(2) of the Restatement (2d) of Contracts.  It appears from Mr. Rarpoport's letter that California follows the Restatment (and Cardozo) on this issue.


About this Blog, Commentary, In the News | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference NY Times "Ethicist" on Charitable Subscriptions:


Nice post. But every time I see a picture of Cardozo, I wonder if he is a forebear of Conan O'Brien.

Posted by: Jeff Lipshaw | Mar 21, 2012 6:29:02 AM

No descendant of Justice Cardozo would have lost his Tonight Show slot to Jay Leno (unless of course unbeknownst to me Leno is a descendant of Felix Frankfurter).

Posted by: Jeremy Telman | Mar 21, 2012 9:05:30 AM

As Cardozo never married, nor had any romantic attachments according to his biographer, direct descendants are unlikely.

Posted by: Otto | Mar 22, 2012 12:19:25 PM

All the more intriguing. Maybe Conan O'Brien is a long lost illegitimate descendant of Cardozo.

Posted by: Jeff Lipshaw | Mar 25, 2012 1:32:22 PM

Post a comment

If you do not complete your comment within 15 minutes, it will be lost. For longer comments, you may want to draft them in Word or another program and then copy them into this comment box.