ContractsProf Blog

Editor: Myanna Dellinger
University of South Dakota School of Law

Tuesday, September 13, 2005

Barnhizer on bargaining inequalities

Daniel_barnhizer How (or whether) disparities in bargaining power ought to be taken into account in Contract law is one of the great recurring themes in Contract scholarship.  Daniel Barnhizer (Michigan State) weighs in with an ambitious and interesting take, Bargaining Power in Contract Theory.  Here's the abstract:

This Article analyzes the role that legal conceptions of bargaining power play in defining the jurisprudence of contract law. Contract law cannot ignore bargaining power asymmetries.   Unchecked power imbalances in the bargaining context soon become indistinguishable from naked coercion, and at some level the imbalance undermines both the consent of the weaker party and the legitimacy of the resulting bargain. The debate over the role of the legal doctrine of inequality of bargaining power and subdoctrines such as unconscionability and duress has largely focused on whether and how the state should intervene in individual private agreements to correct perceived power disparities. While bargaining power disparities may be difficult to analyze in these individual cases, legal conceptions of bargaining power may also be useful in defining the boundaries of contract law. Specifically, where both parties to a transaction possess some ability to affect the outcome of that transaction, they may take advantage of the relatively flexible and unregulated regime of private contract. In other types of transactions - such as labor agreements, consumer credit contracts and intrafamily gifts - one or both parties lack legally cognizable bargaining power and the resulting transaction is subject to relatively greater degrees of public ordering. At this macro level, bargaining power provides both a positive and normative explanation for why some promises are enforceable in contract and others are regulated under relatively more intrusive public orderings.

[Frank Snyder]

Recent Scholarship | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Barnhizer on bargaining inequalities: