Friday, October 12, 2012

Daily Read: Vikram Amar on Scalia on Originalism

Over at Justia today, ConLawProf Vikram Amar (pictured) responds to Justice Scalia's well-publicized and controversial remarks that originalism makes issues such as "homosexuality" and abortion "easy."

AmarAmar writes:

But to say that originalism is important and helpful does not mean that it is easy. To see this, let us first look at what it would mean to say that all constitutional disputes should be analyzed and resolved by exclusive reference to originalism.  It would mean, among other things, that the Supreme Court’s cases from the 1960s holding that states may not impose poll taxes or property qualifications on the franchise, because under the Equal Protection Clause and other parts of Section One of the Fourteenth Amendment there is an individual right to vote for legislative elections, are flawed.  So too would be the cases holding, again under the Equal Protection Clause, that states cannot draw voter districts of significantly different sizes (thereby discriminating against urban voters); originalism would call into question the idea that the Equal Protection Clause guarantees “one person, one vote” in legislative elections.

 Amar does not add - - - and perhaps he does not need to - - - any discussion of Bush v. Gore

Instead, Amar focuses his argument on cases that Scalia himself implicated.  Amar's ultimate conclusion is probably one that almost every law student, and most ConLawProfs, could credit:

My point here is not to disagree with any particular outcome that Justice Scalia supports in these or other areas—in fact, I sometimes agree with his constitutional bottom line, and at other times do not.  But my goal here has simply been to suggest that all of this stuff is a long way from “easy.”

RR

http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/conlaw/2012/10/daily-read-vikram-amar-on-scalia-on-originalism.html

Due Process (Substantive), Equal Protection, Supreme Court (US), Theory | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfae553ef017d3ca90e91970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Daily Read: Vikram Amar on Scalia on Originalism:

Comments

Post a comment