Friday, May 23, 2014

Commencement Speakers and The Giver


Much has been written about the protests at various schools over proposed commencement speakers.  I am not sure I have much original to add to the many thoughts that have been shared on the issue (See, e.g., Jonathan Adler (Case Western), The Volokh Conspiracy; Stephen Carter (Yale), Bloomberg; Glenn Harlan Reynolds (Tennessee), USA Today; Editorial Board, Washington Post), but the controversy did make me think of the dystopian society in The Giver where “Sameness” rules.

One of my younger sisters recently accepted a job with Walden Media, which is producing the upcoming film version of The Giver with The Weinstein Company (shameless plug - in theatres August 15, 2014).  My sister was amazed that I hadn’t read The Giver, as it is supposedly regular middle school reading, but it looks like the book (published in 1993) was not in the curriculum in time for me.  Yes, I feel older every day. 

Anyway, in a single day a few weeks ago, I read a borrowed copy of The Giver, which was a nice break from legal treatises and law review articles.  While I understand the “Elders” in The Giver were trying to protect people by ridding the community of differences, pain, conflict, and ridicule, it made for a shallow existence. 

Some of my most valuable moments in school occurred when I faced views I disagreed with and had to grapple with them.  As a professor, the most valuable conversations are often those with knowledgeable people with opposing opinions and ideas.  Going forward, I hope we will encourage engagement with those who see things differently than we do and continue the search for a more nuanced understanding of complex issues.

Business School, Film, Haskell Murray, Law School | Permalink


As one who believes in more speech rather than less (as distinguished from trying to drown out another), let me laud the conclusory paragraph. I engage others whose perspectives are different in order to "test and weigh" my own. I abhor political correctness so long as the dialogue is not demeaning.

It seems we are promulgating a society of "the offended." If often seems we have created a society of "egg shells."

Posted by: Tom N | May 24, 2014 5:40:38 AM

Great post, and I completely agree. When I see news of the commencement protests, I can't help but think of the from the Life of Brian, where Brian says, "You are all individuals!" and the crowd responds in unison, "Yes! We are all individuals!"

Posted by: Joshua Fershee | May 27, 2014 10:33:00 AM

Post a comment

If you do not complete your comment within 15 minutes, it will be lost. For longer comments, you may want to draft them in Word or another program and then copy them into this comment box.